Submarine power cable explained

A submarine power cable is a transmission cable for carrying electric power below the surface of the water.[1] These are called "submarine" because they usually carry electric power beneath salt water (arms of the ocean, seas, straits, etc.) but it is also possible to use submarine power cables beneath fresh water (large lakes and rivers). Examples of the latter exist that connect the mainland with large islands in the St. Lawrence River.

Design technologies

High voltage or high current

Since electric power is a product of electric current and voltage: P=IU,one can increase, in principle, the power transmitted by a cable by either increasing the input voltage or the input current. In practice, however, electric power transmission is more energy efficient, if high-voltage (rather than high-current) powerline are used.[2]

This can be explained by the following back-of-the-envelope calculation:[3] Define: P=power, U=voltage, I=current, i=in, o=out then: input power Pi=Ii*Ui and the output power Po=Io*Uo . Due to the conservation of charge the current's absolute value is conserved (both in DC and AC cases), thus the output current is the same as the input current |Io| = |Ii| =I . Then the voltage drop is : Ui-Uo = I*R or Uo = Ui-I*R, the output power is Po=I*Uo = I* (Ui-I*R) and the energy efficiency = Po/Pi = I* (Ui-I*R)/ I*Ui = Ui/Ui-IR/Ui=1- IR/Ui .The latter formula shows, that decreasing operating current and increasing input voltage improves the efficiency of electric power transmission via an electric conductor.

AC or DC

Most electrical power transmission systems above ground use alternating current (AC), because transformers can easily change voltages as needed (see War of the currents for historical details). High-voltage direct current transmission requires expensive and inefficient converters at each end of a direct current line to interface to an alternating current grid.

However this logic fails for below-the-ground electric powerlines, such as submarine electric cables. This is because the capacitance between the cable and its surrounding (i.e. the capacitance of capacitance of a single cable) is not negligible, when the cable is immersed into an electrically conducting salt water.

The inner and outer conductors of a cable form the plates of a capacitor, and if the cable is long (on the order of tens of kilometres), this will result in a noticeable phase shift between voltage and current, thus significantly decreasing the efficiency of the transmitted power, which is a vector product of current and voltage.[4]

An AC electric powerline under water would require larger, therefore more costly, conductors for a given quantity of usable power to be transmitted.

When the reasons for high voltage transmission, the preference for AC, and for capacitive currents are combined, one can understand why there are no underwater high electric power cables longer than 1000 km (see the table in "Operational submarine power cables" section below).

Conductor

As explained in the 2 preceding sections, the purpose of submarine power cables is the transport of electric current at high voltage. The electric core is a concentric assembly of inner conductor, electric insulation, and protective layers (resembling the design of a coaxial cable).[5] Modern three-core cables (e.g. for the connection of offshore wind turbines) often carry optical fibers for data transmission or temperature measurement, in addition to the electrical conductors.The conductor is made from copper or aluminum wires, the latter material having a small but increasing market share. Conductor sizes ≤ 1200 mm2 are most common, but sizes ≥ 2400 mm2 have been made occasionally. For voltages ≥ 12 kV the conductors are round so that the insulation is exposed to a uniform electric field gradient. The conductor can be stranded from individual round wires or can be a single solid wire. In some designs, profiled wires (keystone wires) are laid up to form a round conductor with very small interstices between the wires.

Insulation

Three different types of electric insulation around the conductor are mainly used today.Cross-linked polyethylene (XLPE) is used up to 420 kV system voltage. It is produced by extrusion, with an insulation thickness of up to about 30 mm; 36 kV class cables have only 5.5 – 8 mm insulation thickness. Certain formulations of XLPE insulation can also be used for DC.Low-pressure oil-filled cables have an insulation lapped from paper strips. The entire cable core is impregnated with a low-viscosity insulation fluid (mineral oil or synthetic). A central oil channel in the conductor facilitates oil flow in cables up to 525 kV for when the cable gets warm but rarely used in submarine cables due to oil pollution risk with cable damage.Mass-impregnated cables have also a paper-lapped insulation but the impregnation compound is highly viscous and does not exit when the cable is damaged. Mass-impregnated insulation can be used for massive HVDC cables up to 525 kV.

Armoring

Cables ≥ 52 kV are equipped with an extruded lead sheath to prevent water intrusion. No other materials have been accepted so far. The lead alloy is extruded onto the insulation in long lengths (over 50 km is possible). In this stage the product is called cable core. In single-core cables the core is surrounded by concentric armoring. In three-core cables, three cable cores are laid-up in a spiral configuration before the armoring is applied.The armoring consists most often of steel wires, soaked in bitumen for corrosion protection. Since the alternating magnetic field in AC cables causes losses in the armoring, those cables are sometimes equipped with non-magnetic metallic materials (stainless steel, copper, brass).

Operational submarine power cables

Alternating current cables

Alternating-current (AC) submarine cable systems for transmitting lower amounts of three-phase electric power can be constructed with three-core cables in which all three insulated conductors are placed into a single underwater cable. Most offshore-to-shore wind-farm cables are constructed this way.

For larger amounts of transmitted power, the AC systems are composed of three separate single-core underwater cables, each containing just one insulated conductor and carrying one phase of the three phase electric current. A fourth identical cable is often added in parallel with the other three, simply as a spare in case one of the three primary cables is damaged and needs to be replaced. This damage can happen, for example, from a ship's anchor carelessly dropped onto it. The fourth cable can substitute for any one of the other three, given the proper electrical switching system.

ConnectingConnectingVoltage (kV)Length(km)YearNotes
150 135 2021 Two 3-core XLPE cables with total capacity of 2x200MVA. 174 km total length including the underground segments. Maximum depth 1000m. Total cost 380 million EUR. It is the longest submarine/underground AC cable interconnection in the world.[6] [7] [8]
138 33 1956 "The cable became operational on 25 September 1956" [9]
Mainland British Columbia to Texada Island to Nile Creek TerminalVancouver Island / Dunsmuir Substation 52535 1985 Twelve, separate, oil filled single-phase cables. Nominal rating 1200 MW.[10]
Tarifa, Spain
(Spain-Morocco interconnection)
Fardioua, Morocco
through the Strait of Gibraltar
400261998A second one from 2006[11] Maximum depth: 660m (2,170feet).[12]
Norwalk, CT, USANorthport, NY, USA13818 A 3 core, XLPE insulated cable
SicilyMalta220 952015 The Malta–Sicily interconnector
Mainland SwedenBornholm Island, Denmark6043.5The Bornholm Cable
Mainland ItalySicily380381985Messina Strait submarine cable replacing the "Pylons of Messina". A second 380 kV cable began operation in 2016
GermanyHeligoland3053[13]
Negros IslandPanay Island, the Philippines138
Douglas Head, Isle of Man,Bispham, Blackpool, England90104 1999The Isle of Man to England Interconnector, a 3 core cable
Wolfe Island, Canada
for the Wolfe Island Wind Farm
Kingston, Canada2457.82008The first three-core XLPE submarine cable for 245 kV[14]
Cape Tormentine, New BrunswickBorden-Carleton, PEI138172017Prince Edward Island Cables[15]
Taman Peninsula, Mainland RussiaKerch Peninsula, Crimea220572015[16]

Direct current cables

See also: List of HVDC projects.

NameConnectingBody of waterConnectingkilovolts (kV)Undersea distanceYearNotes
Baltic CableGermanyBaltic SeaSweden450 250km (160miles)1994
Basslinkmainland State of VictoriaBass Straitisland State of Tasmania, Australia500290km (180miles)[17] 2005
BritNedNetherlandsNorth SeaGreat Britain450260km (160miles)2010
COBRAcableNetherlandsNorth SeaDenmark320325km (202miles)2019
Cross Sound CableLong Island, New YorkLong Island SoundState of Connecticut150 2003
East–West InterconnectorDublin, IrelandIrish SeaNorth Wales and thus the British grid200 186km (116miles)2012
Estlinknorthern EstoniaGulf of Finlandsouthern Finland330 105km (65miles)2006
Fenno-SkanSwedenBaltic SeaFinland400 233km (145miles)1989
HVDC Cross-ChannelFrench mainlandEnglish ChannelEngland270 73km (45miles)1986 very high power cable (2000 MW)
HVDC GotlandSwedish mainlandBaltic SeaSwedish island of Gotland150 98km (61miles)19541954, the first HVDC submarine power cable (non-experimental)[18] Gotland 2 and 3 installed in 1983 and 1987.
HVDC Inter-IslandSouth IslandCook StraitNorth Island35040km (30miles)1965between the power-rich South Island (much hydroelectric power) of New Zealand and the more-populous North Island.
HVDC Italy-Corsica-Sardinia (SACOI)Italian mainlandMediterranean Seathe Italian island of Sardinia, and its neighboring French island of Corsica200 385km (239miles) 19673 cables, 1967, 1988, 1992[19]
HVDC Italy-GreeceItalian mainland - Galatina HVDC Static InverterAdriatic SeaGreek mainland - Arachthos HVDC Static Inverter400160km (100miles)2001Total length of the line is 313 km (194 mi)
HVDC Leyte - LuzonLeyte IslandPacific OceanLuzon in the Philippines1998
HVDC MoyleScotlandIrish SeaNorthern Ireland within the United Kingdom, and thence to the Republic of Ireland250 63.5km (39.5miles)2001500MW
HVDC Vancouver IslandVancouver IslandStrait of Georgiamainland of the Province of British Columbia280 33 km 1968 In operation in 1968 and was extended in 1977
Kii Channel HVDC systemHonshuKii ChannelShikoku250 50km (30miles) 2000 in 2010 the world's highest-capacity long-distance submarine power cable (rated at 1400 megawatts). This power cable connects two large islands in the Japanese Home Islands
KontekGermanyBaltic SeaDenmark1995
Konti-Skan[20] SwedenKattegatDenmark400 149km (93miles) 1965Commissioned:1965 (Kontiskan 1);1988 (Kontiskan 2)

Decommissioned:2006 (Kontiskan 1)

Maritime LinkNewfoundlandAtlantic OceanNova Scotia200 170km (110miles) 2017500 MW link went online in 2017 with two subsea HVdc cables spanning the Cabot Strait.[21]
Nemo-Link[22] BelgiumNorth SeaUnited Kingdom400 140km (90miles) 2019
Neptune CableState of New JerseyAtlantic OceanLong Island, New York500104.6km (65miles)[23] 2003
NordBaltSwedenBaltic SeaLithuania300400km (200miles)2015Operations started on February 1, 2016 with an initial power transmission at 30 MW.[24]
NordLinkErtsmyra, NorwayNorth SeaBüsum, Germany500623km (387miles)2021Operational May 2021[25]
NorNedEemshaven, NetherlandsFeda, Norway450580km (360miles)2012700 MW in 2012 previously the longest undersea power cable[26]
North Sea LinkKvilldal, Suldal, in Norway, Cambois near BlythNorth Sea United Kingdom, Norway515720km (450miles)20211.4 GW the longest undersea power cable
Shetland HVDC ConnectionShetland islandsNorth SeaScotland600 260km (160miles) 2024
Skagerrak 1-4NorwaySkagerrakDenmark (Jutland)500 240km (150miles) 19774 cables - 1700 MW in all[27]
SwePolPolandBaltic SeaSweden450 2000
Western HVDC LinkScotlandIrish SeaWales600 422km (262miles)2019Longest 2200 MW cable, first 600kV undersea cable[28]

Submarine power cables under construction

Proposed submarine power cables

See also

External links

Notes and References

  1. https://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/17/business/energy-environment/17power.html Underwater Cable an Alternative to Electrical Towers
  2. https://www.google.com/books/edition/Electric_Power_Transmission_and_Distribu/KpY1hpKKwdQC?hl=en&gbpv=1&bsq=high%20voltage%20power%20transmission page 436: "The possibility for a reduction in current for an increase in voltage has an important economic aspect of power transmission. In the case of a transmission system the load, which the conductors can carry, will depend on the heating effects of the current. Hence, of the current can be reduced by using a high voltage, the resistance can be increased without incurring additional losses and causing a greater temperature rise. Therefore, we can use smaller conductors, thus, saving cost. Alternatively, with the same conductor the losses and voltage drops are reduced and the efficiency of transmission is increased."
  3. see the derivation at https://www.google.com/books/edition/Electric_Power_Transmission_and_Distribu/KpY1hpKKwdQC?hl=en&gbpv=1&bsq=high%20voltage%20power%20transmission, page. 436.
  4. Ardelean, M.; Minnebo, P. The suitability of seas and shores for building submarine power interconnections. Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev 2023, 176, 10.1016/j.rser.2023.113210.
  5. "Submarine Power Cables - Design, Installation, Repair, Environmental aspects", by T Worzyk, Springer, Berlin Heidelberg 2009
  6. Web site: Crete-Peloponnese: The record-breaking interconnection is completed. IPTO.
  7. Web site: Crete – Peloponnese Interconnection. Selection of tenderers for the cables of one of the most important submarine interconnection projects globally. admieholding.gr. 2020-03-05. 2020-10-18. https://web.archive.org/web/20201018221426/http://admieholding.gr/crete-peloponnese-interconnection-selection-of-tenderers-for-the-cables-of-one-of-the-most-important-submarine-interconnection-projects-globally/?lang=en. dead.
  8. Web site: Crete – Peloponnese 150kV AC Interconnection.. www.researchgate.net.
  9. Web site: The 132,000 volt submarine cable in the Mainland - Vancouver Island interconnection : part 3, cable laying - RBCM Archives. search-bcarchives.royalbcmuseum.bc.ca.
  10. Web site: British Columbia Transmission Corporation Application for Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity For Vancouver Island Transmission Reinforcement Project. https://web.archive.org/web/20210526212756/https://www.bcuc.com/Documents/Proceedings/2005/DOC_7818_B1-1%20(Part%201%20of%202)%20VITR%20CPCN%20Application%20and%20Appx%20A-D.pdf. live. 2021-05-26.
  11. http://tdworld.com/underground-tampd/bridge-between-two-continents "A Bridge Between Two Continents"
  12. "Energy Infrastructures in the Mediterranean: Fine Accomplishments but No Global Vision", Abdelnour Keramane, IEMed Yearbook 2014 (European Institute of the Mediterranean), under publication. Consulted 28 March 2014.
  13. Web site: Mit der Zukunft Geschichte schreiben. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20110719053515/http://www.kreiszeitung-wesermarsch.de/Home/region/nordenham_Mit-der-Zukunft-Geschichte-schreiben-_arid%2C159098_regid%2C1.html. 19 July 2011. Dithmarscher Kreiszeitung. de.
  14. Wolfe Island Wind Project. Canadian Copper CCBDA. 2008. 156. 3 September 2013.
  15. News: P.E.I.'s underwater electric cable project officially plugged in - New underwater cables supply about 75% of the Island's electricity . 1 August 2020 . CBC News . Aug 29, 2017.
  16. [:ru:Энергомост в Крым|The corresponding page on Russian Wikipedia]
  17. Web site: Basslink - About. 11 February 2018. www.basslink.com.au.
  18. Web site: European Subsea Cables Association - Submarine Power Cables . www.escaeu.org.
  19. Web site: Sardinia's electricity transmission network . 2009.
  20. Web site: THE KONTI-SKAN HVDC SCHEME . www.transmission.bpa.gov . https://web.archive.org/web/20050902175957/http://www.transmission.bpa.gov/cigresc14/Compendium/KONTI.htm . 2005-09-02 .
  21. Web site: Maritime Link Infrastructure. Emera Newfoundland and Labrador.
  22. News: New UK-Belgium power link to start operating on Jan. 31. Reuters . Nina . Chestney . January 14, 2019. www.reuters.com.
  23. Web site: Home. Neptune Regional Transmission System.
  24. Web site: Power successfully transmitted through NordBalt cable . . 2016-02-01 . 2016-02-02.
  25. Web site: NordLink - TenneT. 2021-10-17. www.tennet.eu.
  26. Web site: The Norned HVDC Cable Link . www05.abb.com.
  27. Web site: Skagerrak An excellent example of the benefits that can be achieved through interconnections. . new.abb.com . 2016-01-21 . 2016-01-20 . https://web.archive.org/web/20160120170439/http://new.abb.com/systems/hvdc/references/skagerrak . dead .
  28. Web site: None . www.westernhvdclink.co.uk.
  29. Web site: Lower Churchill Project . Nalcor Energy . 2013-06-08 . 2016-11-29 . https://web.archive.org/web/20161129063257/http://www.nalcorenergy.com/Lower-Churchill-Project.asp . dead .
  30. Web site: Kabel til England - Viking Link. energinet.dk. 2015-11-12. 2017-03-23. https://web.archive.org/web/20170323121607/http://www.energinet.dk/DA/ANLAEG-OG-PROJEKTER/Anlaegsprojekter-el/Kabel-til-England-Viking-Link/Sider/default.aspx. dead.
  31. Web site: Denmark - National Grid . . 2016-02-03 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20160303152334/http://www2.nationalgrid.com/About-us/European-business-development/Interconnectors/denmark/ . 2016-03-03 .
  32. Web site: Quadrilateral agreement inked on Black Sea electric cable Link. dead. 2022-12-17. 2022-12-17. https://web.archive.org/web/20221217180428/https://english.news.cn/20221217/80224854014b4bcc8eeae745be840556/c.html.
  33. News: 2020-07-30. Australia Fast Tracks Approval Process for $16 Billion Solar Power Export Project. en-US. Reuters. 2020-11-03. 0362-4331.
  34. http://www.euroasia-interconnector.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/EuroAsia_Interconnector_Project_and_Progress_English.pdf The EuroAsia Interconnector document
  35. News: ENERGY: End to electricity isolation a step closer . . 2017-10-19 . 2017-01-04.
  36. News: Cyprus group plans Greece-Israel electricity link . https://web.archive.org/web/20120126080043/http://af.reuters.com/article/energyOilNews/idAFL5E8CN25B20120123 . dead . 2012-01-26 . Reuters . 2012-01-23.
  37. Web site: Territory to Study Linking Power Grid to Puerto Rico . https://web.archive.org/web/20110716134527/http://stcroixsource.com/content/news/local-news/2010/06/29/territory-study-linking-power-grid-puerto-rico. dead. stcroixsource.com . June 29, 2010. July 16, 2011.
  38. http://www.geni.org/globalenergy/library/technical-articles/transmission/eesoc.org/hvdc-transmission-and-india-sri-lanka-power-link/index.shtml HVDC Transmission & India-Sri Lanka Power Link www.geni.org 2010
  39. Web site: Malta signs €182 million interconnector contract. Times of Malta. 15 December 2010 .
  40. Web site: Čavčić . Melisa . World's 'most ambitious' subsea interconnector igniting zest for clean power superhubs: Embracing NATO-L to reinforce energy security bonds between America and Europe . Offshore Energy . July 31, 2024 . October 28, 2024.
  41. Web site: Taiwan power company-Taipower Events . www.taipower.com.tw . dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20140517160458/http://www.taipower.com.tw/e_content/content/events/events01-1.aspx?sid=2. 2014-05-17.
  42. News: Iceland's volcanoes may power UK . London . The Guardian . Damian . Carrington . 2012-04-11.
  43. http://www.fablink.net/ FAB
  44. Web site: EuroAfrica Interconnector. www.euroafrica-interconnector.com.
  45. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-02-08/electricity-cable-aims-to-link-cyprus-egypt-greece Electricity Cable Aims to Link Cyprus, Egypt, Greece
  46. Web site: ENERGY: EuroAfrica 2,000MW cable boosts Egypt-Cyprus ties. February 8, 2017. Financial Mirror.
  47. Web site: EEHC, Euro Africa Company sign MoU to conduct a feasibility study to link Egypt, Cyprus, Greece . dailynewsegypt.com . February 6, 2017.
  48. Web site: 22 January 2016 . Proposed 11kV Submarine Cables Replacement Connecting Liu Ko Ngam and Pak Sha Tau Tsui at Kat O . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20220313211034/https://www.epd.gov.hk/eia/register/english/permit/ep4612013/documents/4wbseimsr/pdf/4wbseimsr.pdf . 13 March 2022 . 13 March 2022 . Government of Hong Kong.