Zionist as a pejorative explained

Zionist as a pejorative or Zio is a term commonly used by "anti-Zionists" as described by academics,[1] political parties and civil rights organizations as antisemitic, including but not limited to the American Jewish Committee (AJC), Anti-Defamation League (ADL), the British Labour Party and the Liberal Democrats.

History of pejorative use

The use of the compounded "Zio" as a slur is first recorded by the 1990 edition of the American Jewish Yearbook as in the term "Zionazi", spraypainted as graffiti on the campus of SUNY-Binghamton. The website WikiZio, run by former grand wizard of the Ku Klux Klan (KKK) David Duke uses "Zio" as a noun or as a hyphenated or unhyphenated adjective. Other variations of "Zio-" include "Zio-Communism", "Zio-economics", "Zio-supremacism", and "Zio-occupied America".

Ben Samuels, writing for Haaretz, has claimed that the term was popularized first by David Duke and then later by leftists and members of the British Labour Party.[2] In 2016, the British Labour Party released an inquiry into antisemitism stating that "Epithets such as [...] 'Zio' and others should have no place in Labour party discourse going forward." Speaking at the inquiry's launch, party leader Jeremy Corbyn stated that Zio' is a vile epithet that follows in a long line of earlier such terms that have no place whatsoever in our party."[3]

In 2017, the organizers of the Chicago Dyke March faced accusations of antisemitism after their Twitter account used the term "Zio tears".[4] [5] [6] In April of the same year, Terry Couchman, an election candidate of the British Labour Party, was suspended over his use of "ZioNazi" in a post criticising Israel.[7] [8] Tony Greenstein, another then-member of the British Labour Party, was accused of antisemitism and expelled from the party in 2018 for using the term "Zios" among other allegations.[9] [10]

Reception

According to the American Jewish Committee (AJC), "Zio" is used by antisemites to pass off their antisemitism as "anti-Zionism", pointing out that "Zio" is an euphemism for "Jew".[11] This view was shared by prominent Jewish civil rights advocacy Anti-Defamation League.[12] Similarly, progressive journals like the Mosaic Magazine referred to "Zio" as a "new anti-Jewish slur".[13] Writer Ariel Sobel of the Jewish Journal also pointed out that "Zio" was an antisemitic slur with roots within antisemitic right-wing extremist circles that had been adopted by some progressives in their activism.[14] Well-known Czech-Israeli Jewish Holocaust historian Yehuda Bauer succinctly called the "Zio-Nazi" slur hate speech.[15]

Zionist as pejorative

During the Israel-Hamas war, the term Zionist became a popular pejorative among the political left.[16] [17] For many Palestinians it is an "ugly" term, because, in their view, it implies the 1948 Palestinian expulsion and flight. In July 2024, Meta made the controversial decision to impose restrictions on the use of the term.[18] [19] This decision was welcomed by the American Jewish Committee.[20], while 73 organizations sent a letter to the Meta, alleging that such a policy "will also encourage the incorrect and harmful conflation of criticism of the acts of the state of Israel with antisemitism."[21] A pro-Palestinian digital rights group further argued that "Zionism is an ideology. It's not a race."[22] David Duke, the former KKK's Grand Wizard, reportedly used it as a slur against Jews based on the fact that Zionism holds such widespread appeal among contemporary Jews that it has become a core part of many of their identity, especially in the US, where 85% American Jews believed in the importance of the US supporting Israel,[23] and the UK, where 80% British Jews identified as Zionist.[24]

See also

Notes and References

  1. Web site: May 31, 2024 . "It's in the Air": Antisemitism and Anti-Israeli Bias at Stanford, and How to Address It A REPORT FROM THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON ANTISEMITISM AND ANTI-ISRAELI BIAS OF THE JEWISH ADVISORY COMMITTEE AT STANFORD UNIVERSITY .
  2. News: 'Violent History' of 'Zio': How Chicago's Dyke March Adopted an anti-Semitic Slur Dear to White Supremacists . . 18 July 2017 . 2023-03-29 . Samuels . Ben .
  3. Web site: Labour antisemitism report tells members to stop using 'Hitler, Nazi and Holocaust metaphors' . . 30 June 2016 . 2023-03-30.
  4. News: Chicago Dyke March Collective Revels in 'Zio Tears' in Twitter Rant . . 14 July 2017 . 2023-03-30 . Sommer . Allison Kaplan .
  5. This Is a Safe Space. No Jews Allowed. . 25 July 2017 . . 2023-03-30 . Stern . Mark Joseph .
  6. Web site: Chicago Dyke March Drops Pretense, Deploys Anti-Semitic Term Popularized by Neo-Nazis . . 2023-03-30.
  7. News: Jewish News. Exclusive: Labour candidate suspended over 'ZioNazi storm troopers' posts.
  8. Web site: Campaign Against Antisemitism. Labour Candidate Terry Couchman Reportedly Suspended for Posts Attacking "ZioNazi Final Solution" and "Jewish Organizations". 14 April 2017 .
  9. Web site: Tony Greenstein's 'notorious antisemite' libel claim dismissed by court . . 2023-03-29.
  10. Web site: Britain's Labour expels Jewish anti-Zionist activist over 'anti-Semitic' remarks . . 2023-03-30.
  11. Web site: Zionist / "Zio" . April 2021 . . 2023-03-29.
  12. Web site: Anti-Defamation League. Anti-Zionism as Antisemitism: How Anti-Zionist Language from the Left and Right Vilifies Jews.
  13. Web site: Who're You Calling a "Zio"? . . 2023-03-29.
  14. Web site: Why Are Progressives Using an Anti-Semitic Slur Coined by the KKK? . 19 June 2019 . . 2023-03-29.
  15. Web site: Feinberg . Tali . 2021-11-11 . "Hit back hard," Holocaust scholar says of "Zio-Nazi" slur . 2024-09-17 . Jewish Report . en-ZA.
  16. Web site: Antisemitism Policy Trust. GLOSSARY OF ANTISEMITIC TERMS.
  17. Web site: The Forward. In groundbreaking new policy, Facebook says calling someone a 'Zionist pig' is antisemitic. 9 July 2024 .
  18. News: Jewish News Syndicate. US antisemitism envoy lauds Meta ban on use of 'Zionist' as slur.
  19. Web site: 2024-07-09 . AJC Welcomes Meta Policy Cracking Down on Antisemitic and Anti-Israeli Hate Speech AJC . 2024-10-07 . www.ajc.org . en.
  20. News: Bhuiyan . Johana . Paul . Kari . 2024-02-10 . Meta's review of hate speech policy sparks concern of further censorship of pro-Palestinian content . 2024-10-07 . The Guardian . en-GB . 0261-3077.
  21. News: Nix . Naomi . Dwoskin . Elizabeth . 2024-02-09 . Inside Meta, a debate over when the word 'Zionist' is hate speech . 2024-10-07 . Washington Post . en-US . 0190-8286.
  22. Web site: American Jewish Committee. AJC Survey Shows American Jews are Deeply and Increasingly Connected to Israel. 10 June 2024 .
  23. News: The Jewish Chronicle. Eight out of ten British Jews identify as Zionist, says new poll.