Schoof cabinet explained

Cabinet Name:Schoof cabinet
Cabinet Type:Cabinet
Jurisdiction:the Netherlands
Flag:Flag of the Netherlands.svg
Flag Border:true
Date Formed:2 July 2024
Government Head:Dick Schoof
Deputy Government Head Title:Deputy Prime Ministers
State Head:Willem-Alexander
Members Number:16
Political Parties:
    Legislature Status:Right-wing,[1] majority government (coalition government)
    88/150
    Legislature Term:2023–present
    Incoming Formation:2023–2024 formation
    Previous:Fourth Rutte cabinet
    State Head Title:Monarch
    Government Head Title:Prime Minister

    The Schoof cabinet is the cabinet of the Netherlands, sworn in on 2 July 2024. Led by independent politician and civil servant Dick Schoof as prime minister of the Netherlands, the cabinet was formed by the Party for Freedom (PVV), the People's Party for Freedom and Democracy (VVD), the New Social Contract (NSC) and the Farmer–Citizen Movement (BBB) after the 2023 Dutch general election.

    Formation

    See main article: 2023–2024 Dutch cabinet formation.

    Under informateurs Elbert Dijkgraaf and Richard van Zwol, the four parties (the right-wing populist PVV, the conservative liberal VVD, the Christian democratic NSC, and the agrarian BBB) reached the outline of a coalition agreement, titled "Hope, Courage, and Pride", on 16 May 2024.[2] They agreed to form an extra-parliamentary cabinet, which they defined as a cabinet with a greater distance to parliamentary groups in the House of Representatives. Votes in parliament of coalition parties were not bound on issues not covered in the agreement, such as pensions, as long as they would not impact the budget.[3] Van Zwol was appointed formateur on 22 May. On 11 June, the four parties agreed on the names of candidates and the distribution of ministerial posts. The cabinet consists of 29 members, the same amount as its predecessor, of which 16 are ministers. Three new ministerial posts were created, the Minister of Asylum and Migration, the Minister of Climate and Green Growth, and the Minister of Housing and Spatial Planning; and it includes one minister without portfolio, namely the Minister for Foreign Trade and Development Cooperation.[4] The cabinet was sworn in on 2 July 2024.[5]

    Following the formation, the cabinet was tasked with expanding the outline of the coalition agreement into a governing agreement.[6] It was finalized by the Council of Ministers on 6 September 2024 and presented on 13 September, ahead of the presentation of the 2025 Netherlands budget on Dutch; Flemish: [[Prinsjesdag]].[7] [8] The concluded in October 2024 that nine proposals, including the declaration of an asylum crisis, violated the principles of the rule of law, while another 28 were considered risks. Six proposals, such as the "right to make a mistake", could strengthen the rule of law.[9]

    Term

    Asylum

    See main article: Schoof cabinet asylum measures.

    The coalition agreement included plans to issue a "well-substantiated" statutory instrument to suspend certain provisions of the Aliens Act and to introduce an Asylum Crisis Act without delay. It was agreed that no new asylum applications would be processed and that the Dispersal Act would be revoked.[10] [11] [12] The coalition parties called their migration policy the most stringent and extensive in history.[13] In October 2024, the coalition parties agreed that the proposal to use emergency powers would be abandoned, and new legislation would be introduced to enact asylum measures, most of which were outlined in the coalition agreement, along with some additional provisions.[14] [15] [16]

    In a September 2024 letter to the European Commission, Minister of Asylum and Migration Marjolein Faber requested an opt-out for the Netherlands from European asylum and migration legislation in case of a treaty amendment. Such an exception can only be granted by the European Council, and the Commission responded that no treaty amendments were pending.[17] [18] Hungary later joined the Netherlands in requesting an opt-out.[19]

    November 2024 Amsterdam attacks

    In the wake of the November 2024 Amsterdam attacks, in which supporters of the Israeli football club Maccabi Tel Aviv F.C. were targeted, Schoof said that he was "ashamed" and "horrified by the antisemitic attacks on Israeli citizens."[20] [21] Following an 11 November Council of Ministers meeting, he blamed a specific group of young people with a migration background for the attacks, and he said that the events pointed to a broader integration issue. Integration state secretary Jurgen Nobel stated that a significant portion of Islamic youth did not endorse Dutch norms and values.[22] [23] On 15 November, State Secretary Nora Achahbar announced her resignation citing "polarizing interactions during the past weeks." Reports circulated of offensive, radical, and potentially racist remarks about the Amsterdam attacks during the Council of Ministers meeting. Schoof invited the leaders of the four coalition parties to join the cabinet for crisis talks to avert a cabinet collapse, and they finally agreed that other cabinet members of NSC would stay on. Schoof denied allegations of racism within the cabinet and coalition parties, and he refused to release minutes of the meeting, which opposition parties had requested.[24] [25] [26] [27] [28] Achahbar later denied that her departure was because of racism, and members of parliament Rosanne Hertzberger and Femke Zeedijk of NSC resigned in her support.[29] [30]

    Cabinet changes

    State Secretary for Tax Affairs and the Tax Administration Folkert Idsinga (NSC) resigned on 1 November 2024, citing a perceived lack of trust by the House. PVV leader Geert Wilders had joined opposition parties in demanding transparency about Idsinga's retirement savings, which included business interests and could create conflicts of interest. His savings, valued at over €6 million in 2023, were managed by a foundation for the duration of his term, and Idsinga refused to provide more visibility, citing his privacy.[31] [32] Idsinga was succeeded by Tjebbe van Oostenbruggen.[33]

    Defense

    In response the Russian invasion of Ukraine, coalition parties agreed to increase defense spending to adhere to the NATO target of 2% of GDP. Minister Ruben Brekelmans and State Secretary Gijs Tuinman announced €2.4 billion in increased yearly funding for the Netherlands Armed Forces in September 2024. This would go towards attracting more personnel and the purchase of munitions, 46 Leopard 2A8 battle tanks, six F-35 fighter jets, two Anti-Submarine Warfare Frigates, and several NH90 military helicopters. The Netherlands had been left without tanks since 2011 because of budget cuts.[34] [35] In addition, a further €2.6 billion was allocated towards the purchase of short- and medium-range air defense systems.[36]

    Development aid

    The Schoof cabinet renamed the portfolio of "development cooperation" to "development" (or "development aid" in Dutch). It intends to cut the yearly allocated budget by €2.4 billion, over a third of its total, starting in 2027. The percentage of the budget spent on sheltering asylum seekers in the Netherlands would be contained to 10%, and aid related to water management and food security would be prioritized.[37]

    Agriculture

    The Netherlands had been mandated by the European Union to stop the deterioration of nature in Natura 2000 sites by 2030, and goals with regard to nitrogen deposition had been enshrined in national legislation.[38] The coalition agreement reduced the fund allocated towards addressing the nitrogen crisis from €25 billion to €5 billion.[6] In September 2024, Minister Femke Wiersma terminated the National Program for Rural Areas, which had been created by the fourth Rutte cabinet in response to the crisis and which tasked provinces with devising plans to improve the quality of nature and water based on a national fund.[39] [40]

    Wiersma presented the outline of her alternative plans and a provisional breakdown of the €5 billion in funding in late November 2024. The cabinet aimed to increase agricultural lands designated as nature reserves from 100000ha to 280000ha by expanding subsidies for farmers. The cabinet allocated between €1.25 billion and €2.5 billion towards innovations to reduce nitrogen emissions, and it planned to set emissions targets for farms instead of prescribing certain measures. The same amount would be available for a voluntary buyout scheme for farmers considering to leave the sector. Furthermore, Wiersma plans to postpone enforcement of nitrogen emissions regulations for a group of farmers left without a permit due to a 2019 Court of State ruling for another three years. The responded that farmers would remain uncertain about their future because of the latter.[41] [42]

    Education

    The cabinet decided to cut funding for higher education and science by €1 billion per year in its 2025 budget. This would be achieved through lowering the number of international students, increasing tuition for students exceeding the standard duration, reducing money allocated to the Fund for Research and Science, and scrapping research grants. The latter had been created by the previous cabinet.[43] The announcement sparked significant protests from universities, student organizations and labor unions. In November 2024, the General Education Union (AOb) and Dutch Federation of Trade Unions (FNV) organized demonstrations against the cuts in Utrecht, and after these were cancelled due to security concerns, in The Hague on November 25th.[44] University administrators argued the cuts would damage the Netherlands' position as a knowledge economy and research hub.[45] A particular point of contention was the policy to reduce international student numbers through stricter language requirements and higher tuition fees. Critics, including the Province of Limburg, argued this would disproportionately affect universities in border regions that rely heavily on international cooperation.[46] The PVV party advocated for even deeper cuts, particularly targeting university support staff and English-language programs.[47]

    Cabinet type

    The coalition parties agreed to form an extra-parliamentary cabinet. In particular, Pieter Omtzigt, the leader of NSC, had insisted on an alternative to the typical majority cabinet after having campaigned on a "new governance culture" in the election. An extra-parliamentary cabinet would be defined by greater distance between the cabinet and the parliamentary groups of coalition parties in the House of Representatives. Informateur Kim Putters recommended the formation of an "extra-parliamentary program cabinet", meaning the coalition parties would draft a shorter coalition agreement, which the cabinet would later expand into a governing agreement.[48]

    A few months after its creation, newspaper NRC concluded the Schoof cabinet no longer resembled an extra-parliamentary cabinet. It noted that frequent talks occurred between parliamentary leaders and cabinet members and that coalition parties negotiated with the cabinet about the 2025 budget. Political scientist Arco Timmermans agreed the cabinet could not be considered extra-parliamentary, saying that more effort from parliamentary leaders would be required to keep distance.[48] Wim Voermans, another political scientists, argued that a cabinet could only be extra-parliamentary if there would have been no involvement from the parliament in its formation and the drafting of its agreement.[49]

    Cabinet members

    The party affiliations shown below indicate the party by which a cabinet member was given. Some cabinet members are a member of a different party or of no party.

    See also

    Notes and References

    1. News: 11 June 2024 . Dutch parties agree on final formation of rightwing government, Wilders says . 4 July 2024 . Reuters.
    2. News: Partijleiders nu definitief akkoord • Presentatie verschoven naar vanochtend . 16 May 2024 . 16 May 2024 . nl . . Party leaders definitively in agreement • Presentation postponed to this morning . 16 May 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240516040547/https://nos.nl/collectie/13962/liveblog/2520280-partijleiders-nu-definitief-akkoord-presentatie-verschoven-naar-vanochtend . live .
    3. News: De voordracht van Schoof als premier roept veel nieuwe vragen op . subscription . 29 May 2024 . Sie . Puck . 1 June 2024 . nl . . Schoof's nomination as prime minister raises many new questions . 30 May 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240530042456/https://fd.nl/politiek/1518479/de-voordracht-van-schoof-als-premier-roept-veel-nieuwe-vragen-op . live .
    4. News: Verdeling kabinetsposten nu officieel: drie nieuwe ministeries . 12 June 2024 . 12 June 2024 . nl . . Division of cabinet posts official: Three new ministries . 12 June 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240612100916/https://nos.nl/collectie/13962/artikel/2524196-verdeling-kabinetsposten-nu-officieel-drie-nieuwe-ministeries . live .
    5. Web site: New Dutch Cabinet sworn in today 7 months after election. NL Times. 2 July 2024. 2 July 2024. 3 July 2024. https://web.archive.org/web/20240703061502/https://nltimes.nl/2024/07/02/new-dutch-cabinet-sworn-today-7-months-election. live.
    6. News: Beoogd premier Schoof belandt in een politiek mijnenveld . subscription . 2024-05-31 . Van den Dool . Pim . 2024-06-01 . nl . . Prime minister-designate Schoof will end up in a political minefield . 2024-05-31 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240531202817/https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2024/05/31/beoogd-premier-schoof-belandt-in-een-politiek-mijnenveld-a4200662 . live .
    7. News: Kabinet is het na stevig en lang overleg eens over regeerprogramma . Slomp . Priscilla . Oving . Sanne . 6 September 2024 . 8 September 2024 . nl . . Cabinet has reached governing agreement after firm and long discussion .
    8. News: Kabinet ambitieus over asiel en bouwen, maar stuit bij mest op grenzen . 13 September 2024 . 21 September 2024 . nl . . Cabinet ambitious on asylum and construction, but is constrained on manure .
    9. News: Juristen: regeerprogramma op meerdere punten niet rechtsstatelijk . 10 October 2024 . 13 October 2024 . nl . . Jurists: Governing agreement incompatible with the rule of law on several points .
    10. News: PVV-minister Faber zegt 'asielcrisis' en meteen is er verwarring . subscription . 22 August 2024 . Van Buuren . Yara . Kieskamp . Wilma . 27 August 2024 . nl . . PVV minister Faber says 'asylum crisis' and confusion ensues .
    11. News: Hij komt er, de asielcrisiswet, maar hoe en wanneer blijft de vraag . subscription . 26 August 2024 . Meijer . Remco . 29 August 2024 . nl . . The Asylum Crisis Act will come, but it remains unclear when and how .
    12. News: Hij komt er, de asielcrisiswet, maar hoe en wanneer blijft de vraag . 26 August 2024 . Meijer . Remco . 12 October 2024 . nl . . The Asylum Crisis Act will arrive, but how and when remains to be seen .
    13. News: De machtsoverdracht op Justitie: 'Wij houden van de oude bewindslieden en zoeken een nieuwe relatie' . subscription . 2 July 2024 . Meijer . Remco . 8 July 2024 . nl . . The transfer of power at Justice: 'We like the old government members and are looking for a new relationship' .
    14. News: Kabinet wil zo snel mogelijk asielwet, 'opvang moet tijdelijk zijn' . 25 October 2024 . 27 October 2024 . nl . . Cabinet wants asylum law as soon as possible, 'sheltering should be temporary' .
    15. News: Geert Wilders was standvastig en dreigde met een kabinetscrisis. Nu buigt hij toch het hoofd . subscription . 23 October 2024 . Van Eijsden . Auke . 27 October 2024 . nl . . Geert Wilders was persistent and threatened with a cabinet crisis. He now bows his head after all .
    16. News: Kabinet scherpt asielbeleid verder aan met 'noodmaatregelenwet' . subscription . 25 October 2024 . Van den Dool . Pim . 28 October 2024 . nl . . Cabinet sharpens asylum policy further with 'emergency measures bill' .
    17. News: Nederland informeert EU over 'opt-out'-plannen, 'iets van de lange adem' . 18 September 2024 . 2 November 2024 . nl . . The Netherlands informs EU about 'opt-out' plans, 'something for the long term' .
    18. News: Opt-out briefje Faber ging expres naar 'verkeerde adres', zegt premier Schoof . 16 October 2024 . 2 November 2024 . nl . . Opt-out letter Faber was sent to the 'wrong address' on purpose, according to Prime Minister Schoof .
    19. News: Hongarije wil Nederland volgen met opt-out voor asiel en migratie . 19 September 2024 . 2 November 2024 . nl . . Hungary wants to follow the Netherlands with opt-out for asylum and migration .
    20. https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/amsterdam-clashes-football-israeli-1.7377872 "Dutch PM 'ashamed' by Amsterdam attacks on Israeli soccer fans,"
    21. Web site: Eugenia Yosef . Edward Szekeres . Lauren Kent . 8 November 2024 . Israeli soccer fans attacked in Amsterdam, in what Dutch authorities call antisemitic incidents . 8 November 2024 . CNN . en.
    22. News: Premier Schoof ziet groot probleem met de integratie: 'Hun gedrag is schokkend, moreel volstrekt ontaard' . 11 November 2024 . Du Pré . Raoul . 11 November 2024 . nl . . Prime Minister Schoof observes major issue with integration: 'Their behavior is shocking, completely morally corrupt' .
    23. News: Na geweld in Amsterdam laait politieke discussie over integratie weer op . 11 November 2024 . 16 November 2024 . nl . . Following violence in Amsterdam, the political debate about integration is sparked again .
    24. News: Geen debat over uitspraken in ministerraad, notulen blijven geheim . 19 November 2024 . 20 November 2024 . nl . . No debate about remarks during Council of Ministers meeting, minutes remain secret .
    25. News: Kabinet-Schoof bleef na crisisberaad overeind, maar 'schade is behoorlijk groot' . 16 November 2024 . 20 November 2024 . nl . . Schoof cabinet did not collapse due to crisis talks, but 'damage is significant' .
    26. News: Val kabinet afgewend: Achahbar vertrekt, andere NSC'ers blijven in kabinet . 15 November 2024 . 15 November 2024 . nl . . Cabinet collapse prevented: Achahbar will depart, other NSC members will remain in the cabinet .
    27. News: Kabinet-Schoof na nieuwe crisis verder, stabiliteit blijft een vraagteken . 16 November 2024 . 16 November 2024 . nl . . Schoof cabinet will continue after new crisis, stability remains questionable .
    28. News: Integratiedebat brengt verdeeld kabinet-Schoof aan het wankelen . 15 November 2024 . Hendrickx . Frank . Du Pré . Raoul . 16 November 2024 . nl . . Integration debate causes divided Schoof cabinet to shake .
    29. News: Oud-staatssecretaris Achahbar ontkent dat ze is opgestapt vanwege racisme . 19 November 2024 . 20 November 2024 . nl . . Former State Secretary Achahbar denies that she stepped down because of racism .
    30. News: Twee NSC-Kamerleden stappen op na vertrek Achahbar, hekelen 'gebrek aan fatsoen' . 19 November 2024 . 20 November 2024 . nl . . Two NSC MPs step down following departure Achahbar, denouncing 'lack of civility' .
    31. News: Waarin belegde staatssecretaris Idsinga (Fiscaliteit) zijn pensioen? Tweede Kamer wil meer helderheid wegens mogelijke belangenverstrengeling . subscription . 30 October 2024 . De Haan . Marko . 30 October 2024 . nl . . In what companies did State Secretary Idsinga (taxation) invest his retirement savings? House of Representatives wants more visibility due to potential conflicts of interest .
    32. News: Dutch junior finance minister quits after questions over his personal investments . . 1 November 2024 . 2 November 2024 . Corder . Mike.
    33. News: 's Ochtends beëdigd, vanavond al ontslag? Bijzondere eerste dag voor nieuwe staatssecretaris . Verweij . Elodie . . 15 November 2024 . nl . Sworn in in the morning, resigning tonight? Special first day for new state secretary . 15 November 2024 .
    34. News: Defensienota: leger redt het niet met alleen beroepsmilitairen en reservisten . 5 September 2024 . 7 September 2024 . nl . . Defense memo: Army needs more than just professional soldiers and reservists .
    35. News: Tanks, vliegtuigen en fregatten zijn niet genoeg: defensie heeft de samenleving nodig . subscription . 5 September 2024 . Derix . Steven . 7 September 2024 . nl . . Tanks, aircraft, and frigates are not enough: Defense needs society .
    36. News: Kabinet koopt 46 tanks en investeert miljarden in luchtafweer voor eigen leger . 14 October 2024 . 14 October 2024 . nl . . Cabinet buys 46 tanks and invests billions in air defense for own army .
    37. News: Kabinet wil snoeien in ontwikkelingshulp: 'Als iets wordt wegbezuinigd, is de kans heel klein dat het terugkomt' . subscription . 24 September 2024 . Oost . Georgia . Hugo . Schiffers . 25 September 2024 . nl . . Cabinet wants to reduce development aid: 'If something is cut, the chances of it returning are very slim' .
    38. News: Hoeveel speelruimte heeft minister Femke Wiersma in Brussel? Het schrappen van de huidige regels kan wrevel wekken . subscription . 10 September 2024 . Uijtewaal . Rosa . 11 September 2024 . nl . . How much room does Minister Femke Wiersma have in Brussels? Eliminating current regulations could create resentment .
    39. News: Minister Wiersma stelt het geduld van de Kamer op de proef: de stikstofstrategie is weg, maar waar blijft de nieuwe? . subscription . 4 September 2024 . Du Pré . Raoul . 4 September 2024 . nl . . Minister Wiersma tests the Houses's patience: The nitrogen strategy is gone, but when will its replacement come? .
    40. News: Kabinet schrapt huidige stikstofplannen, provincies reageren verrast . 4 September 2024 . 4 September 2024 . nl . . Cabinet eliminates current nitrogen plans, provinces respond surprised .
    41. News: Minister Wiersma schetst stikstofplan, nog zonder uitwerking . subscription . 29 November 2024 . Blankestijn . Maureen . She . Puck . 1 December 2024 . nl . . Minister Wiersma drafts nitrogen plans, still without details .
    42. News: Minister komt met stikstofplan: meer geld voor natuur en voor boeren die willen stoppen . 29 November 2024 . Van Soest . Hans . 1 December 2024 . nl . . Minister present nitrogen plans: More funds for nature and for farmer who want to quit .
    43. News: Het kabinet bezuinigt niet op universitaire banen maar op onderzoeksbeurzen. De schade blijft even groot, zeggen universiteiten . subscription . 23 September 2024 . Kammer . Claudia . 23 September 2024 . nl . . The cabinet will not cut jobs at universities but will cut funding for research grants. The damage will be as significant, according to universities .
    44. News: Painting banners and cutting red squares . 14 November 2024 . Observant . 20 November 2024.
    45. News: Noodkist uit voor UM . 14 November 2024 . De Nieuwester . nl . 20 November 2024.
    46. News: Provincie stuurt opnieuw brandbrief over instroom buitenlandse studenten naar Den Haag . 19 November 2024 . L1 . nl . 20 November 2024.
    47. News: PVV wil dat kabinet nog meer gaat bezuinigen op het hoger onderwijs . 20 November 2024 . ScienceGuide . nl . 20 November 2024.
    48. News: Van het 'extraparlementaire' karakter van het kabinet is bijna niets meer over – voor zover het überhaupt van de grond kwam . subscription . 4 October 2024 . Aharouay . Lamyae . 6 October 2024 . nl . . Little is left of the cabinet's 'extra-parliamentary' characteristics – as far as it ever materialized .
    49. Wim Voermans: 'Dit is geen extraparlementair kabinet en dat moeten we ook niet willen' . 9 September 2024 . Voermans . Wim . Ilse Schröder . 6 October 2024 . nl . . Wim Voermans: 'This is no extra-parliamentary cabinet, and we should not even want one' .