Proto-Hakka Explained

Proto-Hakka (also called Common Neo-Hakka, CNH) is the reconstructed proto-language from which all Hakka varieties descend. Like all branches of the Sinitic language family, proto-Hakka is difficult to reconstruct through the comparative method due to its multistratal lexicon.

History

It is believed that Sinitic migration into what is now Southern China started in the Qin dynasty, after which a slow yet steady population continued to migrate southwards, up until the early Tang dynasty. The part of the population who lived in the highlands then underwent frequent amicable cultural exchange with the She people (as opposed to the Ho-nte, also classified by the Chinese government under the She ethnonym), who are believed to have descended from an indigenous people. The aforementioned Sinitic migrants likely spoke an early Sinitic language, and through this cultural exchange, the Sinitic language was transmitted to the ancestral She.

Later large migration waves due to the An-Shi Chaos and the fall of the Northern Song dynasty to the Jurchen-led Jin dynasty led to large increases of population, and conflicts between the migrants and pre-existing Highlanders of Sinitic ethnicity. Once the conflict had calmed down, the two groups intermingled, and the language of these migrants provided superstrata on one of the pre-existing Highlander languages, which became the multi-stratal proto-Hakka.

While Neo-Hakka and She share common innovations, there are She-internal innovations that are not shared with Neo-Hakka. This implies that Neo-Hakka is the sister branch to She Chinese, forming a bifurcating tree from their common ancestor. This proto-language is in turn closely related to the paraphyletic group of stem Hakka, or "Paleo-Hakka".

Classification

To reconstruct proto-Hakka, the language varieties to be included must first be decided. O'Connor's earlier reconstruction only utilizes data on Moiyan-like Hakka varieties, which Coblin calls "Mainstream Hakka". The dialects included in Coblin's reconstruction are known as "Neo-Hakka", which includes Mainstream Hakka, but also varieties in southern Jiangxi which are not mutually intelligible with Mainstream Hakka and whose speakers do not consider themselves Hakka people.

The following critera are used to determine Neo-Hakka varieties:^{[1] [2]}

• Sonorant-initial syllables corresponding to the Light Rising tone in Qieyun system appear in the Dark Level and Light Rising tones, and which tone they occur with are lexically determined.
• The copula should be a form of 係 *hei6.
• The first-person singular pronoun should take the form /ŋai/ in the popular register, or be derivable from an earlier */ŋai/.
• The verb "to eat" should be a form of 食 *šik8.

Phonology

Given the varieties to be included, the comparative method can then be applied to arrive at a reconstruction of this language. This reconstruction is described below.

Consonants

The following consonants are reconstructed for Common Neo-Hakka:

		Labial	Dental	Postalveolar	Velar	Glottal
Nasal		/pronounced as /link//	/pronounced as /link//	/ň/	/pronounced as /link//
Plosive		/pronounced as /link//	/pronounced as /link//		/pronounced as /link//
		/pronounced as /link//	/pronounced as /link//		/pronounced as /link//
Affricate			/pronounced as /link//	/tš/
			/pronounced as /link//	/tšʰ/
Fricative		/pronounced as /link//	/pronounced as /link//	/š/		/pronounced as /link//
Approximant		/pronounced as /link//	/pronounced as /link//

Much like modern Hakka varieties, the consonants /m n ŋ p t k/ can appear in syllable-final position.

The consonant inventory is similar to modern Sinitic languages, and preserves the dental-postalveolar distinction found in other Sinitic languages like Modern Standard Mandarin or Hoisanese, as well as the postalveolar nasal, preserved in Shanghainese.

Glides

Common Neo-Hakka glides consist of pronounced as //i//, pronounced as //u//, or a combination thereof.

Vowels

!! Front! Central! Back

Close	pronounced as /link/	pronounced as /link/	pronounced as /link/
Mid	pronounced as /link/	(pronounced as /link/) (pronounced as /link/)	pronounced as /link/
Open		pronounced as /link/

Vowels in parentheses appear in loanwords from some Northern Chinese variety, likely some Northern Ming or Qing Mandarin koine or even early Modern Standard Mandarin.

Finals

The following chart lists all of the finals in Common Neo-Hakka, which are a combination of glide, nucleus, and coda. Examples with the reconstructed final are written to the right, in parentheses if multiple variants with different finals can be reconstructed to the proto-language.

! colspan="2" && rowspan="2"

	Nucleus
pronounced as //i//	pronounced as //ɨ//	pronounced as //u//	pronounced as //e//	pronounced as //ə// pronounced as //ɚ//	pronounced as //o//	pronounced as //a//	pronounced as //ŋ̩//
Coda	pronounced as /∅/	pronounced as / -i / 移 pronounced as / -ui / 未 pronounced as / -iui / (銳)	pronounced as / -ɨ / 思	pronounced as / -u / 烏 pronounced as / -iu / 於	pronounced as / -e / (事) pronounced as / -ie / (鋸)	pronounced as / -ə / (而) pronounced as / ɚ / 爾	pronounced as / -o / 多 pronounced as / -io / 茄 pronounced as / -uo / 火	pronounced as / -a / 啞 pronounced as / -ia / 夜 pronounced as / -ua / 花	pronounced as / ŋ̩ / (女)
	pronounced as //i//				pronounced as / -ei / (買)		pronounced as / -oi / (海) pronounced as / -ioi / (歲) pronounced as / -uoi / 灰	pronounced as / -ai / 帶 pronounced as / -iai / 低 pronounced as / -uai / 淮
	pronounced as //u//				pronounced as / -eu / 歐 pronounced as / -ieu / 又		pronounced as / -ou / 老	pronounced as / -au / 包 pronounced as / -iau / 腰
	pronounced as //m//	pronounced as / -im / 音			pronounced as / -em / 森		pronounced as / -om / 敢	pronounced as / -am / 帆 pronounced as / -iam / 鹽
	pronounced as //n//	pronounced as / -in / 因		pronounced as / -un / 溫 pronounced as / -iun / 暈	pronounced as / -en / 恩		pronounced as / -on / 安 pronounced as / -ion / 遠 pronounced as / -uon / 酸	pronounced as / -an / 反 pronounced as / -ian / 煙 pronounced as / -uan / 關
	pronounced as //ŋ//	pronounced as / -iŋ / 英		pronounced as / -uŋ / (翁) pronounced as / -iuiŋ / 永	pronounced as / -eŋ / 生 pronounced as / -ueŋ / 衡		pronounced as / -oŋ / 幫 pronounced as / -ioŋ / 羊 pronounced as / -uoŋ / 光	pronounced as / -aŋ / 硬 pronounced as / -iaŋ / 餅 pronounced as / -uaŋ / 橫 pronounced as / -uiaŋ / 兄
	pronounced as //p//	pronounced as / -ip / 揖			pronounced as / -ep / 澀		pronounced as / -op / 鴿	pronounced as / -ap / 鴨 pronounced as / -iap / 葉
	pronounced as //t//	pronounced as / -it / 一		pronounced as / -ut / 骨 pronounced as / -iut / 出	pronounced as / -et / 蝨		pronounced as / -ot / 割 pronounced as / -iot / 決 pronounced as / -uot / 刮 pronounced as / -uiot / 血	pronounced as / -at / 八 pronounced as / -iat / 熱 pronounced as / -uat / (括)
	pronounced as //k//	pronounced as / -ik / 役		pronounced as / -uk / 屋 pronounced as / -iuk / 浴	pronounced as / -ek / 得 pronounced as / -uek / 或		pronounced as / -ok / 惡 pronounced as / -iok / 藥 pronounced as / -uok / 廓	pronounced as / -ak / 白 pronounced as / -iak / 石

The finals reconstrcted violate phonotactic rules expected from the Mainstream Hakka dialects, such as forbidding velar codas after front vowels. This is due to the existence of Hakka languages, like, that allow both velars and dental consonants to act as codas after front vowels, thus the distinction must be reconstructed to their last common ancestor.

Tones

Common Neo-Hakka has 7 tones. Historical voiced stops become aspirated in the areal tone split. The traditional tone categories and their names are listed below:

		Tone category				- ! Level 平	Rising 上 ! Going 去	Entering 入	- ! rowspan="2"	Tone register ! Dark 陰	1. 陰平 Dark Level	3. 陰上 Dark Rising	5. 陰去 Dark Going	7. 陰入 Dark Entering	- ! Light 陽	2. 陽平 Light Level		6. 陽去 Light Going	8. 陽入 Light Entering

Due to the diverse realization of tonal values in the descendants, precise tone values were not reconstructed. For example, the Dark Level tone is realized as pronounced as /[˦]/ (44) in Moiyan (Meixian), whereas in Ngiaupin (Raoping) it is pronounced as /[˩]/ (11) and in Ningdu it is pronounced as /[˦˨]/ (42) or pronounced as /[˦˧]/ (43). Tones 7 and 8, the Entering tones, are distinguished by their stop codas, and so do not count as independent tones phonemically. However, they are included separately as they are considered independent categories in Chinese historical linguistics.

Vocabulary

Certain vocabulary items can also be reconstructed for proto-Hakka, a selection of which is provided below. Only reconstructions for forms surviving in more than two dialects are included by Coblin.

English gloss ! Reconstruction	Written form	-	is / are (copula)	pronounced as / hei6 /	係	-	eat	pronounced as / šik8 /	食	-	I	pronounced as / ŋai1 / / pronounced as / ŋai2 / / pronounced as / ŋai3 /		-	you (singular)	pronounced as / ŋ̩2 ~ *ŋ̩3 / / pronounced as /ni1/ / pronounced as / ňi2 /	-	that	pronounced as / kai5 / /pronounced as / kai2 / / pronounced as / kai3 /		-	existential negative ("not have / not exist")	pronounced as / mau2 / / pronounced as / muo2 /	-	son	pronounced as / lai6 /	孻	-	daughter	pronounced as / ŋ̩3 / / pronounced as / ňiu3 / / pronounced as / nie /	女	-	pronounced as / muoi5 *tse3 / / pronounced as / muoi5 *tsɨ3 /	妹子	-	face	pronounced as / mian5 /	面	-	eye	pronounced as / ŋan3 /	眼	-	pronounced as / ŋan3 *tšiu1 /	眼珠	-	pronounced as / muk7 *tšiu1 /	目珠	-	mouth	pronounced as / tšoi5 /		-	house	pronounced as / vuk7 /	屋	-	mountain	pronounced as / san1 /	山	-	pronounced as / liaŋ1 /	嶺	-	cooked rice	pronounced as / fan6 / / pronounced as / pʰon6 /	飯	-	egg	pronounced as / tšʰiun1 /	春	-	pronounced as / luon3 /	卵	-	pronounced as / tʰan3 /	蛋	-	meat	pronounced as / ňiuk7 /	肉	-	wear (clothing)	pronounced as / tšok7 /	著	-	stand	pronounced as / kʰi1 /	企／徛	-	speak / talk	pronounced as / koŋ3 /	講	-	pronounced as / va6 /	話	-	know	pronounced as / ti1 / (pronounced as / tek7 /)	知（得）	-	pronounced as / hiau3 *tek7 /	曉得

Bibliography

• Book: Coblin, W. South . Common Neo-Hakka: A Comparative Reconstruction . 2019 . Taipei: Institute of Linguistics, Academia Sinica . Language and linguistics Monograph Series 63 . 978-986-54-3228-7.

Notes and References

1. Book: Norman, Jerry Lee . What is a Kèjiā dialect? In Editorial Board of Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Sinology (ed.) . 1989 . Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Sinology . 323-344 . Taipei: Academia Sinica.
2. Book: Coblin, W. South . A Study of Comparative Gàn . 2015 . Taipei: Institute of Linguistics, Academia Sinica . Language and linguistics Monograph Series 58 . VI Varia and Concluding Remarks . 9789860459265.