Paleobiota of the Chinle Formation explained

The Chinle Formation is an extensive geological unit in the southwestern United States, preserving a very diverse fauna of Late Triassic (primarily Norian-age) animals and plants. This is a list of fossilized organisms recovered from the formation.

Amniotes

Archosauromorphs

Phytosaurs

Phytosaurs of the Chinle Formation
GenusSpeciesStateMemberAbundanceNotesImages
Leptosuchus[1] L. crosbiensis
  • Arizona
  • Sonsela
  • Blue Mesa
  • Mesa Redondo
Smilosuchus[2] S. adamanensis
  • Arizona
  • Sonsela
  • Blue Mesa
  • Mesa Redondo
Known from a single skullPreviously referred to Leptosuchus, actually referable to Smilosuchus.
S. gregorii
  • Arizona
  • Sonsela
  • Blue Mesa
  • Mesa Redondo
Known from a handful of skulls.A basal leptosuchomorph.
S. lithodendrorum
  • Arizona
  • Blue Mesa
Known from only one skull.Previously considered synonymous with S. adamanensis.
cf. Paleorhinus[3] Indeterminate
  • Arizona
  • Mesa Redondo
Machaeroprosopus[4] M. buceros
  • Arizona
  • Owl Rock
  • Petrified Forest
  • Sonsela
M. mccauleyi
  • Arizona
  • Owl Rock
  • Petrified Forest
  • Sonsela
M. pristinus
  • Arizona
  • Owl Rock
  • Petrified Forest
  • Sonsela
Pravusuchus[5] P. hortus
  • Arizona
  • Sonsela
Three skulls.A leptosuchomorph phytosaur closely related to Mystriosuchini[6] or Nicrosaurus.[7]
Protome[8] P. batalaria
  • Arizona
  • Sonsela
Partial skull and jaw.A phytosaur originally described as a juvenile Leptosuchus, but probably an unrelated non-leptosuchomorph or mystriosuchin.
Redondasaurus[9] R. gregorii
  • Arizona
  • Utah
  • "Siltstone" / Rock Point
  • Petrified Forest
  • Church Rock
A large late-surviving mystriosuchin phytosaur closely related to Machaeroprosopus (formerly known as Pseudopalatus),[10] and often considered a subgenus of that taxon.

Suchians

Suchians of the Chinle Formation
GenusSpeciesStateMemberAbundanceNotesImages
Acaenasuchus[11] A. geoffreyi
  • Arizona
  • Sonsela
  • Blue Mesa
  • Mesa Redondo
Known from a handful of isolated osteoderms.A controversial suchian based primarily on osteoderms. Some paleontologists have considered Acaenasuchus to be juvenile Desmatosuchus haplocerus scutes, while others considered it a separate genus of small aetosaurs. Most recently it has been reconsidered an aetosauriform related to, but not within, Aetosauria. It is also related to Revueltosaurus (also from the Chinle) and the armored reptile Euscolosuchus from Virginia.[12]
AdamanasuchusA. eisenhardtae
  • Arizona
  • Blue Mesa
Osteoderms and skull and postcranial fragments.A basal desmatosuchine aetosaur related to Calyptosuchus and Scutarx.
Calyptosuchus[13] C. wellesi[14]
  • Arizona
  • Blue Mesa
Common, although "non-armor material is comparatively rare".A basal desmatosuchine aetosaur originally considered a species of Stagonolepis.
Desmatosuchus[15] D. spurensis[16]
  • Arizona
  • Blue Mesa
Numerous osteoderms and other skeletal materialA large desmatosuchin aetosaur which was fairly common in the lower part of the Chinle Formation. Prior to 2008, fossils of D. spurensis were listed as the species D. haplocerus, until it was determined that D. haplocerus was a species name originally based on undiagnostic fossils.
D. smalli[17]
  • Arizona
  • Sonsela?
A single lateral osteoderm.A desmatosuchin aetosaur which is very rare in the Chinle Formation. One of the youngest known occurrences of the genus Desmatosuchus.
EffigiaE. okeeffeae
  • New Mexico
  • "Siltstone"
A six-foot-long shuvosaurid from the Coelophysis quarry of Ghost Ranch.
Hesperosuchus[18] H. agilis
  • Arizona
  • Petrified Forest
  • Blue Mesa
  • Mesa Redondo
An early-diverging crocodylomorph
KryphioparmaK. caerula
  • Arizona
  • Blue Mesa
Osteoderms.Aetosaur described in 2023, probably related to other typothoracines.
Paratypothorax[19] P. andressorum
  • Arizona
  • Blue Mesa
  • Sonsela
OsteodermsA significant number of researchers feel that the North American material referred to the German Paratypothorax species P. andressorum by Hunt and Lucas in 1992 is actually distinct.
Indeterminate[20]
  • Arizona
  • New Mexico
  • Sonsela
Osteoderms and minor postcranial fragments.A paratypothoracin typothoracine aetosaur known from isolated material similar to more complete specimens from Germany.[21]
Parrishia[22]

Notes and References

  1. "Vertebrate Fauna; Parasuchia; Leptosuchus adamanensis, L. crosbiensis, and L. gregorii," Irmis (2005) p. 72, 74
  2. Long, R.A. and Murray, P.A. 1995. Late Triassic (Carnian and Norian) Tetrapods from the Southwestern United States. New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin 4. pp. 254.
  3. "Vertebrate Fauna; Parasuchia; 'Paleorhinus sp.'" Irmis (2005) p. 72
  4. "Vertebrate Fauna; Parasuchia; Pseudopalatus pristinus, P. buceros, and P. mccauleyi," Irmis (2005) p. 74-75
  5. Stocker. Michelle R.. 2010-09-01. A new taxon of phytosaur (Archosauria: Pseudosuchia) from the Late Triassic (Norian) Sonsela Member (Chinle Formation) in Arizona, and a critical reevaluation of Leptosuchus Case, 1922. Palaeontology. en. 53. 5. 997–1022. 10.1111/j.1475-4983.2010.00983.x. 83536253 . 1475-4983. free. 2010Palgy..53..997S .
  6. Christian F. Kammerer . Richard J. Butler . Saswati Bandyopadhyay . Michelle R. Stocker . 2016 . Relationships of the Indian phytosaur Parasuchus hislopi Lydekker, 1885 . Papers in Palaeontology . 2 . 1 . 1–23 . 10.1002/spp2.1022 . 2016PPal....2....1K . 83780331.
  7. Jones . Andrew S. . Butler . Richard J. . 2018-12-10 . A new phylogenetic analysis of Phytosauria (Archosauria: Pseudosuchia) with the application of continuous and geometric morphometric character coding . PeerJ . en . 6 . e5901 . 10.7717/peerj.5901 . 30581656 . 6292387 . 2167-8359. free .
  8. Stocker . M. R. . 2012 . A new phytosaur (Archosauriformes, Phytosauria) from the Lot's Wife beds (Sonsela Member) within the Chinle Formation (Upper Triassic) of Petrified Forest National Park, Arizona . Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology . 32 . 3 . 573–586 . 10.1080/02724634.2012.649815 . 2012JVPal..32..573S . 129527672.
  9. Hunt, A.P. and Lucas, S.G. 1993. A new phytosaur (Reptilia: Archosauria) genus from the uppermost Triassic of the western United States and its biochronological significance. In; The Nonmarine Triassic, Lucas and Morales, eds., New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin 3.
  10. Hungerbühler A. 2002. The Late Triassic phytosaur Mystriosuchus westphali, with a revision of the genus. Palaeontology 45 (2): 377-418
  11. "Vertebrate Fauna; Stagonolepididae; Acaenasuchus geoffreyi," Irmis (2005) pp. 75-77
  12. Marsh . Adam D. . Smith . Matthew E. . Parker . William G. . Irmis . Randall B. . Kligman . Ben T. . 2020-10-12 . Skeletal Anatomy of Acaenasuchus Geoffreyi Long and Murry, 1995 (Archosauria: Pseudosuchia) and its Implications for the Origin of the Aetosaurian Carapace . Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology . 40 . 4 . e1794885 . 10.1080/02724634.2020.1794885 . 0272-4634 . free. 2020JVPal..40E4885M . 10919/102375 . free .
  13. "Vertebrate Fauna; Stagonolepididae," Irmis (2005) p. 77
  14. "Vertebrate Fauna; Stagonolepididae; Stagonolepis wellesi," Irmis (2005) p. 77
  15. "Vertebrate Fauna; Stagonolepididae," Irmis (2005) p. 75
  16. "Vertebrate Fauna; Stagonolepididae; Desmatosuchus haplocerus," Irmis (2005) p. 75
  17. "Vertebrate Fauna; Stagonolepididae; Desmatosuchus smalli," Irmis (2005) p. 75
  18. "Vertebrate Fauna; Crocodylomorpha; Hesperosuchus agilis," Irmis (2005) pp. 79-80
  19. "Vertebrate Fauna; Stagonolepididae; Paratypothorax sp.," Irmis (2005) p. 78
  20. "Vertebrate Fauna; Stagonolepididae; 'Paratypothorax sp.' and Paratypothorax-Like Forms'," Irmis (2005) p. 78
  21. Parker . William G. . Martz . Jeffrey W. . 2010 . The Late Triassic (Norian) Adamanian–Revueltian tetrapod faunal transition in the Chinle Formation of Petrified Forest National Park, Arizona . Earth and Environmental Science Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh . en . 101 . 3–4 . 231–260 . 10.1017/S1755691011020020 . 2010EESTR.101..231P . 1755-6910 . 140536630.
  22. "Vertebrate Fauna; Poposauridae; Poposaurus gracilis," Irmis (2005) p. 79
  23. "Vertebrate Fauna; 'Rauisuchidae'; Postosuchus kirkpatricki," Irmis (2005) p. 78
  24. "Vertebrate Fauna; Pseudosuchia; 'Revueltosaurus callenderi' and Revueltosaurus hunti,'" Irmis (2005) pp. 71-72
  25. "Vertebrate Fauna; Pseudosuchia; Revueltosaurus callenderi," Irmis (2005) pp. 71-72
  26. "Vertebrate Fauna; Pseudosuchia; Revueltosaurus hunti," Irmis (2005) p. 72
  27. "Vertebrate Fauna; Stagonolepididae; "Desmatosuchus" chamaensis," Irmis (2005) p. 75
  28. Parker. William G.. 2016-01-21. Revised phylogenetic analysis of the Aetosauria (Archosauria: Pseudosuchia); assessing the effects of incongruent morphological character sets. PeerJ. 4. e1583. 10.7717/peerj.1583. 2167-8359. 4727975. 26819845 . free .
  29. Nesbitt . S. J. . Chatterjee . S. . 2024 . The osteology of Shuvosaurus inexpectatus, a shuvosaurid pseudosuchian from the Upper Triassic Post Quarry, Dockum Group of Texas, USA . The Anatomical Record . 307 . 4 . 1175–1238 . 10.1002/ar.25376 . 38258540 . free . 10919/117738 . free.
  30. "Vertebrate Fauna; Stagonolepididae; Typothorax coccinarum," Irmis (2005) pp. 77-78
  31. Emily J. Lessner; Michelle R. Stocker; Nathan D. Smith; Alan H. Turner; Randall B. Irmis; Sterling J. Nesbitt (2016). "A new rauisuchid (Archosauria, Pseudosuchia) from the Upper Triassic (Norian) of New Mexico increases the diversity and temporal range of the clade". PeerJ. 4: e2336. doi:10.7717/peerj.2336.
  32. Weishampel, David B; et al. (2004). "Dinosaur distribution (Late Triassic, North America)." In: Weishampel, David B.; Dodson, Peter; and Osmólska, Halszka (eds.): The Dinosauria, 2nd, Berkeley: University of California Press. Pp. 518–521. .
  33. Zeigler . K. E. . Kelley, S.. Geissman, J. W. . 2008 . Revisions to stratigraphic nomenclature of the Upper Triassic Chinle Group in New Mexico: New insights from geologic mapping, sedimentology, and magnetostratigraphic/paleomagnetic data . Rocky Mountain Geology . 43 . 121–141 . 10.2113/gsrocky.43.2.121 . 2. 2008RMGeo..43..121Z .
  34. "Vertebrate Fauna; Pseudosuchia; Revueltosaurus callenderi," Irmis (2005) p. 81
  35. See Nesbitt et al. (2005) and Ezcurra (2006).
  36. Jeffrey W. Martz . Bryan J. Small . 2019 . Non-dinosaurian dinosauromorphs from the Chinle Formation (Upper Triassic) of the Eagle Basin, northern Colorado: Dromomeron romeri (Lagerpetidae) and a new taxon, Kwanasaurus williamparkeri (Silesauridae) . PeerJ . 7 . e7551 . 31534843 . 10.7717/peerj.7551 . 6730537 . free .
  37. "Vertebrate Fauna; Archosauriformes; Crosbysaurus harrisae," Irmis (2005) p. 71
  38. William G. Parker . Sterling J. Nesbitt . Adam D. Marsh . Ben T. Kligman . Kenneth Bader . 2021 . First occurrence of Doswellia cf. D. kaltenbachi (Archosauriformes) from the Late Triassic (middle Norian) Chinle Formation of Arizona and its implications on proposed biostratigraphic correlations across North America during the Late Triassic . Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology . 41 . 3 . e1976196 . 10.1080/02724634.2021.1976196 . 2021JVPal..41E6196P . 243474578 .
  39. Marsh . Adam D. . Parker . William G. . Nesbitt . Sterling J. . Kligman . Ben T. . Stocker . Michelle R. . 2022 . Puercosuchus traverorum n. gen. n. sp.: a new malerisaurine azendohsaurid (Archosauromorpha: Allokotosauria) from two monodominant bonebeds in the Chinle Formation (Upper Triassic, Norian) of Arizona . Journal of Paleontology . en . 96 . S90 . 1–39 . 10.1017/jpa.2022.49 . 0022-3360 . free. 2022JPal...96S...1M .
  40. Brenen M. Wynd . Sterling J. Nesbitt . Michelle R. Stocker . Andrew B. Heckert . 2020 . A detailed description of Rugarhynchos sixmilensis, gen. et comb. nov. (Archosauriformes, Proterochampsia), and cranial convergence in snout elongation across stem and crown archosaurs . Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology . 39 . 6 . e1748042 . 10.1080/02724634.2019.1748042 . 219917329 .
  41. Lucas. Spencer. Heckert. Andrew. A new species of the enigmatic archosauromorph Doswellia from the Upper Triassic Bluewater Creek Formation, New Mexico, USA. Palaeontology. 2012. 55. 6. 1333–1348. 10.1111/j.1475-4983.2012.01200.x. 2012Palgy..55.1333H . 15431716 . en.
  42. Heckert. A. B. . Nesbitt . S. J. . Stocker . M. R. . Schneider. V. P. . Hoffman . D. K. . Zimmer . B. W. . 2021 . A new short-faced archosauriform from the Upper Triassic Placerias/Downs' quarry complex, Arizona, USA, expands the morphological diversity of the Triassic archosauriform radiation . . 108 . 4 . Article 32 . 10.1007/s00114-021-01733-1 . free . 34213630 . 8253714 . 2021SciNa.108...32H .
  43. Pritchard . Adam C. . Turner . Alan H. . Nesbitt . Sterling J. . Irmis . Randall B. . Smith . Nathan D. . 2015-03-04 . Late Triassic tanystropheids (Reptilia, Archosauromorpha) from northern New Mexico (Petrified Forest Member, Chinle Formation) and the biogeography, functional morphology, and evolution of Tanystropheidae . Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology . en . 35 . 2 . e911186 . 10.1080/02724634.2014.911186 . 2015JVPal..35E1186P . 130089407 . 0272-4634.
  44. "Vertebrate Fauna; Archosauromorpha; Tanytrachelos sp.," Irmis (2005) p. 70
  45. "Vertebrate Fauna; Archosauriformes; Tecovasaurus murryi," Irmis (2005) p. 71
  46. "Vertebrate Fauna; Archosauromorpha; Trilophosaurus buettneri, Trilophosaurus jacobsi, Trilophosaurus sp." Irmis (2005) p. 70
  47. "Vertebrate Fauna; Archosauromorpha; Trilophosaurus buettneri," Irmis (2005) p. 70
  48. "Abstract," Mueller and Parker (2006) p. 119
  49. "Vertebrate Fauna; Archosauromorpha; Trilophosaurus jacobsi," Irmis (2005) p. 70
  50. Ben T. Kligman . Adam D. Marsh . Sterling J. Nesbitt . William G. Parker . Michelle R. Stocker . 2020 . New trilophosaurid species demonstrates a decline in allokotosaur diversity across the Adamanian-Revueltian boundary in the Late Triassic of western North America . Palaeodiversity . 13 . 1 . 25–37 . 10.18476/pale.v13.a3 . free .
  51. "Vertebrate Fauna; Archosauriformes; Vancleavea campi," Irmis (2005) p. 71
  52. Nesbitt . S.J. . Sterling Nesbitt . Stocker . M.R. . Michelle R. Stocker . Small . B.J. . Bryan J. Small . Downs . A. . Alex Downs . November 26, 2009 . The osteology and relationships of Vancleavea campi (Reptilia: Archosauriformes) . Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society . 157 . 4 . 814–864 . 10.1111/j.1096-3642.2009.00530.x . free.
  53. "Vertebrate Fauna; Reptilia incertae sedis; Acallosuchus rectori," Irmis (2005) pp. 69-70
  54. Gabriel S. Gonçalves . Christian A. Sidor . 2019 . A new drepanosauromorph, Ancistronychus paradoxus n. gen. et sp., from the Chinle Formation of Petrified Forest National Park, Arizona, USA . PaleoBios . 36 . ucmp_paleobios_46203 .
  55. Pritchard. Adam C.. Nesbitt. Sterling J.. 2017-10-01. A bird-like skull in a Triassic diapsid reptile increases heterogeneity of the morphological and phylogenetic radiation of Diapsida. Royal Society Open Science. en. 4. 10. 170499. 10.1098/rsos.170499. 29134065. 5666248. 2017RSOS....470499P. 2054-5703.
  56. "Vertebrate Fauna; Parareptilia; Colognathus obscurus," Irmis (2005) p. 69
  57. Pritchard. Adam C.. Turner. Alan H.. Irmis. Randall B.. Nesbitt. Sterling J.. Smith. Nathan D.. 2016-10-24. Extreme Modification of the Tetrapod Forelimb in a Triassic Diapsid Reptile. Current Biology. en. 26. 20. 2779–2786. 10.1016/j.cub.2016.07.084. 27693141. 0960-9822. free. 2016CBio...26.2779P .
  58. Ben T. Kligman . Adam D. Marsh . Hans-Dieter Sues . Christian A. Sidor . 2020 . A new non-mammalian eucynodont from the Chinle Formation (Triassic: Norian), and implications for the early Mesozoic equatorial cynodont record . Biology Letters . 16 . 11 . Article ID 20200631 . 10.1098/rsbl.2020.0631 . 33142088 . 7728676 .
  59. "Vertebrate Fauna; Amniota incertae sedis; Kraterokheirodon colberti," Irmis (2005) p. 69
  60. Burch . H. E. . Eddins . H.-M. S. . Stocker . M. R. . Kligman . B. T. . Marsh . A. D. . Parker . W. G. . Nesbitt . S. J. . 2024 . A small venomous reptile from the Late Triassic (Norian) of the southwestern United States . PeerJ . 12 . e18279 . 10.7717/peerj.18279 . free . 39421413 . 11485104 .
  61. Ben T. Kligman . Adam D. Marsh . William G. Parker . 2018 . First records of diapsid Palacrodon from the Norian, Late Triassic Chinle Formation of Arizona, and their biogeographic implications . Acta Palaeontologica Polonica . 63 . 1 . 117–127 . 10.4202/app.00426.2017 . free .
  62. Jenkins . Kelsey M. . Meyer . Dalton L. . Lewis . Patrick J. . Choiniere . Jonah N. . Bhullar . Bhart-Anjan S. . 2022 . Re-description of the early Triassic diapsid Palacrodon from the lower Fremouw formation of Antarctica . Journal of Anatomy . 241 . 6 . 1441–1458 . 10.1111/joa.13770. 36168715 . 9644968 . 252565757 .
  63. "Vertebrate Fauna; Synapsida; Placerias hesternus," Irmis (2005) p. 82
  64. Jenkins . Xavier A. . Pritchard . Adam C. . Marsh . Adam D. . Kligman . Ben T. . Sidor . Christian A. . Reed . Kaye E. . Kaye Reed . 2020 . Using manual ungual morphology to predict substrate use in the Drepanosauromorpha and the description of a new species . Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology . 40 . 5 . e1810058 . 10.1080/02724634.2020.1810058 . free. 2020JVPal..40E0058J .
  65. Listed as cf. Uatchitodon sp. in "Vertebrate Fauna; Reptilia incertae sedis; Cf. Uatchitodon sp," Irmis (2005) p. 69
  66. Mitchell . Jonathan S. . Heckert . Andrew B. . Sues . Hans-Dieter . 2010 . Grooves to tubes: evolution of the venom delivery system in a Late Triassic "reptile" . Naturwissenschaften . 97 . 12 . 1117–1121 . 2010NW.....97.1117M . 10.1007/s00114-010-0729-0 . 21060984 . 10093308.
  67. "Vertebrate Fauna; Reptilia incertae sedis; Cf. Uatchitodon sp," Irmis (2005) p. 69
  68. Heckert. Andrew B.. Lucas. Spencer G.. Rinehart. Larry F.. Hunt. Adrian P.. 2008-07-01. A New Genus and Species of Sphenodontian from the Ghost Ranch Coelophysis Quarry (upper Triassic: Apachean), Rock Point Formation, New Mexico, Usa. Palaeontology. en. 51. 4. 827–845. 10.1111/j.1475-4983.2008.00786.x. 1475-4983. free. 2008Palgy..51..827H .
  69. Nicholas C. Fraser . Randall B. Irmis . David K. Elliott . 2005 . A procolophonid (Parareptilia) from the Owl Rock Member, Chinle Formation of Utah, USA . Palaeontologia Electronica . 8 . 1 . Article Number 8.1.13 .
  70. "Vertebrate Fauna; Temnospondyli; Apachesaurus gregorii" Irmis (2005) pp. 67-68
  71. Mueller (2007)
  72. Gee . Bryan M. . Parker . William G. . Marsh . Adam D. . Redescription of Anaschisma (Temnospondyli: Metoposauridae) from the Late Triassic of Wyoming and the phylogeny of the Metoposauridae . Journal of Systematic Palaeontology . 2020 . 18 . 3 . 233–258 . 10.1080/14772019.2019.1602855. 2020JSPal..18..233G . 190896742 .
  73. "Vertebrate Fauna; Temnospondyli; Buettneria perfecta" Irmis (2005) p. 67. Note that Koskinonodon was listed under the preoccupied (see Mueller 2007) name Buettneria in the preceding reference.
  74. Jason D. Pardo . Bryan J. Small . Adam K. Huttenlocker . 2017 . Stem caecilian from the Triassic of Colorado sheds light on the origins of Lissamphibia . Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America . 114 . 27 . E5389–E5395 . 10.1073/pnas.1706752114 . 28630337 . 5502650 . 2017PNAS..114E5389P . free .
  75. Kligman . Ben T. . Gee . Bryan M. . Marsh . Adam D. . Nesbitt . Sterling J. . Smith . Matthew E. . Parker . William G. . Stocker . Michelle R. . 2023-01-25 . Triassic stem caecilian supports dissorophoid origin of living amphibians . Nature . 614 . 7946 . en . 102–107 . 10.1038/s41586-022-05646-5 . 36697827 . 9892002 . 2023Natur.614..102K . 256272986 . 1476-4687. 10919/113568 . free .
  76. Michelle R. Stocker . Sterling J. Nesbitt . Ben T. Kligman . Daniel J. Paluh . Adam D. Marsh . David C. Blackburn . William G. Parker . 2019 . The earliest equatorial record of frogs from the Late Triassic of Arizona . Biology Letters . 15 . 2 . Article ID 20180922 . 10.1098/rsbl.2018.0922 . 30958136 . 6405462 . 10919/87931 .
  77. "Vertebrate Fauna; Chondrichthyes; Acrodus sp." Irmis (2005) p. 65
  78. The Petrified Forest and Sonsela Acrodus specimens are actually Reticulodus. See "Vertebrate Fauna; Chondrichthyes; Acrodus sp." Irmis (2005) p. 65 for details.
  79. "Vertebrate Fauna; Chondrichthyes; Lonchidion humblei," Irmis (2005) p. 65
  80. Fischer . Jan . Axsmith . Brian J. . Ash . Sidney R. . 2010-03-01 . First unequivocal record of the hybodont shark egg capsule Palaeoxyris in the Mesozoic of North America . Neues Jahrbuch für Geologie und Paläontologie - Abhandlungen . en . 255 . 3 . 327–344 . 10.1127/0077-7749/2009/0028 . 0077-7749.
  81. "Vertebrate Fauna; Chondrichthyes; Phoebodus sp." Irmis (2005) p. 65
  82. "Vertebrate Fauna; Chondrichthyes; Reticulodus synergus," Irmis (2005) p. 65
  83. "Vertebrate Fauna; Chondrichthyes; 'Xenacanthus' moorei," Irmis (2005) p. 64
  84. Bhat . Mohd Shafi . Ray . Sanghamitra . Datta . P. M. . 2018-09-01 . A new assemblage of freshwater sharks (Chondrichthyes: Elasmobranchii) from the Upper Triassic of India . Geobios . 51 . 4 . 269–283 . 10.1016/j.geobios.2018.06.004 . 2018Geobi..51..269B . 0016-6995.
  85. Listed as cf. Chinlea sp. in "Vertebrate Fauna; Temnospondyli; Cf. Chinlea sp." Irmis (2005) p. 67
  86. "Vertebrate Fauna; Temnospondyli; Cf. Chinlea sp." Irmis (2005) p. 67
  87. "Vertebrate Fauna; Temnospondyli; Arganodus sp." Irmis (2005) p. 67
  88. Listed as "cf. Australosomus" in "Vertebrate Fauna; Osteichthyes; Cf. Australosomus sp." Irmis (2005) p. 66-67
  89. "Vertebrate Fauna; Osteichthyes; Cf. Australosomus sp." Irmis (2005) p. 66-67
  90. Bobb Schaeffer . 1967 . Late Triassic fishes from the western United States . Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History . 135 . 285–342 . 2246/1125 .
  91. Sarah Z. Gibson . 2016 . Redescription and Phylogenetic Placement of †Hemicalypterus weiri Schaeffer, 1967 (Actinopterygii, Neopterygii) from the Triassic Chinle Formation, Southwestern United States: New Insights into Morphology, Ecological Niche, and Phylogeny . PLOS ONE . 11 . 9 . e0163657 . 10.1371/journal.pone.0163657 . 27657923 . 5033578. 2016PLoSO..1163657G . free .
  92. Listed as "cf. Lasalichthyes" in "Vertebrate Fauna; Osteichthyes; Cf. Lasalichthyes sp." Irmis (2005) p. 66
  93. "Vertebrate Fauna; Osteichthyes; Cf. Lasalichthyes sp." Irmis (2005) p. 66
  94. Sarah Z. Gibson . 2013 . A new hump-backed ginglymodian fish (Neopterygii, Semionotiformes) from the Upper Triassic Chinle Formation of southeastern Utah . Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology . 33 . 5 . 1037–1050 . 10.1080/02724634.2013.758125 . 2013JVPal..33.1037G . 129797885 .
  95. Sarah Z. Gibson . 2013 . Biodiversity and Evolutionary History of †Lophionotus (Neopterygii: †Semionotiformes) from the Western United States . Copeia . 2013 . 4 . 582–603 . 10.1643/CI-12-028 . 85755730 . free .
  96. Ben T. Kligman . William G. Parker . Adam D. Marsh . 2017 . First record of Saurichthys (Actinopterygii) from the Upper Triassic (Chinle Formation, Norian) of western North America . Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology . 37 . 5 . e1367304 . 10.1080/02724634.2017.1367304 . 2017JVPal..37E7304K . 134301176 .
  97. Listed as "cf. Turseodus" in "Vertebrate Fauna; Osteichthyes; Cf. Turseodus sp." Irmis (2005) p. 66
  98. "Vertebrate Fauna; Osteichthyes; Cf. Turseodus sp." Irmis (2005) p. 66
  99. Lucas . S.G. . Spencer G. Lucas . Hayden . S.N. . 1989 . Triassic stratigraphy of west-central New Mexico . New Mexico Geological Society Field Conference Guidebook . 40 . 191–211 .
  100. Book: Parker, William G. . 2006 . Museum of Northern Arizona . 0-89734-120-1 . Parker . William G. . 62 . 46–64 . The stratigraphic distribution of major fossil localities in Petrified Forest National Park, Arizona . 71015548 . Ash . Sidney R. . Irmis . Randall B. . http://www.miketaylor.org.uk/dino/nm/Parker2006-pefo-biostratigraphy.pdf.
  101. Lucas . Spencer G. . 2013 . Plant megafossil biostratigraphy and biochronology, Upper Triassic Chinle Group, Western USA . New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin . 61 . 354–365.
  102. Daugherty . Lyman H. . Triassic Roots from the Petrified Forest National Park . 1963 . American Journal of Botany . en . 50 . 8 . 802–805 . 10.1002/j.1537-2197.1963.tb10649.x . 2027.42/141301 . 0002-9122. free .
  103. Book: Ash, Sidney R. . Dawn of the age of dinosaurs in the American Southwest . New Mexico Museum of Natural History . 1989 . Lucas . S.G. . Albuquerque . 189–222 . A catalog of Upper Triassic plant megafossils of the western United States through 1988 . Hunt . A.P. . http://www.npshistory.com/publications/cach/ash-1989.pdf.
  104. Frank H. Knowlton. 1889. New species of fossil wood (Araucarioxylon arizonicum) from Arizona and New Mexico. Proceedings of the United States National Museum. 11. 676. 1–5. 10.5479/si.00963801.11-676.1.
  105. Ash . Sidney R. . 1987 . The Upper Triassic Red Bed Flora of the Colorado Plateau, Western United States . Journal of the Arizona-Nevada Academy of Science . 22 . 1 . 95–105 . 40024387.
  106. Ash . Sidney R. . 1974 . Upper Triassic plants of Canon del Cobre, New Mexico . New Mexico Geological Society Guidebook . 25 . 179–184.
  107. Ash . Sidney R. . 1989 . The upper Triassic Chinle flora of the Zuni Mountains, New Mexico . New Mexico Geological Society . 40 . 225–230 . 10.56577/ffc-40.225. 251985942 .
  108. Web site: 2006 . Trees to Stone . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20150907234346/http://www.nps.gov/pefo/planyourvisit/upload/TreestoStone2006.pdf . September 7, 2015 . October 3, 2010 . National Park Service.
  109. Axsmith . Brian J. . Ash . Sidney R. . 2006 . Two rare fossil cones from the Upper Triassic Chinle Formation in Petrified Forest National Park, Arizona, and New Mexico . Museum of Northern Arizona Bulletin . 62 . 82–94.
  110. Ash . Sidney R. . 1991 . A New Pinnate Cycad Leaf from the Upper Triassic Chinle Formation of Arizona . Botanical Gazette . 152 . 1 . 123–131 . 10.1086/337871 . 83627771 . 0006-8071.
  111. Ash . Sidney R. . 1967 . The Chinle (Upper Triassic) megaflora of the Zuni Mountains, New Mexico . New Mexico Geological Society Fall Field Conference Guidebook . 18 . 125–131 . 10.56577/ffc-18.125. 11630110 .
  112. Ash . Sidney R. . 1973 . Two New Late Triassic Plants from the Petrified Forest of Arizona . Journal of Paleontology . 47 . 1 . 46–53 . 1302865.
  113. Ash . Sidney R. . Chilbinia Gen. Nov., an Archaic Seed Fern in the Late Triassic Chinle Formation of Arizona, USA . 2006 . Palaeontology . en . 49 . 2 . 237–245 . 10.1111/j.1475-4983.2006.00542.x . 2006Palgy..49..237A . 129438630 . 0031-0239.
  114. Ash . Sidney R. . 1972 . Late Triassic plants from the Chinle Formation in north-eastern Arizona . Palaeontology . 15 . 4 . 598–618.
  115. Ash . Sidney . 1996 . Evidence of arthropod-plant interactions in the Upper Triassic of the southwestern United States . Lethaia . en . 29 . 3 . 237–248 . 10.1111/j.1502-3931.1996.tb01657.x . 1996Letha..29..237A . 0024-1164.
  116. Ash . Sidney R. . 2014-06-01 . Contributions to the Upper Triassic Chinle flora in the American southwest . Palaeobiodiversity and Palaeoenvironments . en . 94 . 2 . 279–294 . 10.1007/s12549-014-0150-3 . 2014PdPe...94..279A . 129297877 . 1867-1608.
  117. Ash . Sidney R. . 1970 . Dinophyton, a problematical new plant genus from the Upper Triassic of the south-western United States . Palaeontology . 13 . 4 . 646–663.
  118. Book: Ash, Sidney R. . Brigham Young University Geology Studies . 1978 . 25 . 4: Plant Megafossils . https://www.researchgate.net/publication/292718693.
  119. Ash . Sidney R. . 1977 . An unusual bennettitalean leaf from the Upper Triassic of the south-western United States . Palaeontology . 20 . 3 . 641–659.
  120. Ash . Sidney R. . 1970 . Pagiophyllum simpsonii, a New Conifer from the Chinle Formation (Upper Triassic) of Arizona . Journal of Paleontology . 44 . 5 . 945–952 . 1302730.
  121. Ash . Sidney . Litwin . Ronald J. . 1996 . Two new species of the pinnate microsporophyll Pramelreuthia from the upper Triassic of the southwestern United States . American Journal of Botany . en . 83 . 8 . 1091–1099 . 10.1002/j.1537-2197.1996.tb12807.x.
  122. Ash . Sidney R. . Hasiotis . Stephen T. . 2013-04-01 . New occurrences of the controversial Late Triassic plant fossil Sanmiguelia Brown and associated ichnofossils in the Chinle Formation of Arizona and Utah, USA . Neues Jahrbuch für Geologie und Paläontologie - Abhandlungen . 268 . 1 . 65–82 . 10.1127/0077-7749/2013/0316 . 0077-7749.
  123. Ash . Sidney R. . 1982 . Occurrence of the Controversial Plant Fossil Sanmiguelia cf. S. lewisi Brown in the Upper Triassic of Utah . Journal of Paleontology . 56 . 3 . 751–754 . 1304404.
  124. Ash . Sidney R. . 1968 . A new species of Williamsonia from the Upper Triassic Chinle Formation of New Mexico . Journal of the Linnean Society of London, Botany . en . 61 . 384 . 113–120 . 10.1111/j.1095-8339.1968.tb00108.x.
  125. Web site: 2012 . Fossil Trees or Petrified Wood . October 14, 2021 . University of Arizona.
  126. Herrick . Alisa S. . Fastovsky . David E. . Hoke . Gregory D. . 1999 . OCCURRENCES OF ZAMITES POWELLII IN OLDEST NORIAN STRATA IN PETRIFIED FOREST NATIONAL PARK, ARIZONA . National Park Service Paleontological Research . 4 . 91–95.
  127. Milner . Andrew C. . 2006 . Plant fossils from the Owl Rock or Church Rock members, Chinle Formation, San Juan County, Utah . New Mexico Museum of Natural History & Science Bulletin . 37 . 410–413.
  128. Ash . S.R. . 1969 . Ferns from the Chinle Formation (Upper Triassic) in the Fort Wingate area, New Mexico . United States Geological Survey, Professional Paper . Professional Paper . 613-D . 1–40 . 10.3133/pp613d . 1969usgs.rept....2A . 2330-7102.
  129. Daugherty . Lyman H. . Itopsidema, A New Genus of the Osmundaceae from the Triassic of Arizona . 1960 . American Journal of Botany . en . 47 . 9 . 771–777 . 10.1002/j.1537-2197.1960.tb07164.x.
  130. Ash . Sidney . 2000 . Evidence of oribatid mite herbivory in the stem of a Late Triassic tree fern from Arizona . Journal of Paleontology . en . 74 . 6 . 1065–1071 . 10.1666/0022-3360(2000)074<1065:EOOMHI>2.0.CO;2 . 86324641 . 0022-3360.
  131. Ash . Sidney . Litwin . Ronald J. . Traverse . Alfred . 1982 . The Upper Triassic fern Phlebopteris smithii (Daugherty) Arnold and its spores . Palynology . en . 6 . 1 . 203–219 . 10.1080/01916122.1982.9989242 . 1982Paly....6..203A . 0191-6122.
  132. Ash . Sidney . 1999 . An Upper Triassic Sphenopteris Showing Evidence of Insect Predation from Petrified Forest National Park, Arizona . International Journal of Plant Sciences . en . 160 . 1 . 208–215 . 10.1086/314115 . 85020560 . 1058-5893.
  133. Miller . Charles N. . The Lepidophytic Affinities of the Genus Chinlea and Osmundites Walkeri . 1968 . American Journal of Botany . en . 55 . 1 . 109–115 . 10.1002/j.1537-2197.1968.tb06950.x.
  134. Rothwell . Gar W. . R. Ash . Sidney . 2015 . Internal anatomy of the Late Triassic Equisetocaulis gen. nov., and the evolution of modern horsetails . The Journal of the Torrey Botanical Society . en . 142 . 1 . 27–37 . 10.3159/TORREY-D-14-00042.1 . 86841184 . 1095-5674.
  135. Holt . Edward L. . 1947 . Upright Trunks of Neocalamites from the Upper Triassic of Western Colorado . The Journal of Geology . 55 . 6 . 511–513 . 10.1086/625462 . 1947JG.....55..511H . 129374986 . 0022-1376.
  136. Miller . Gary L. . Ash . Sidney R. . 1988 . The oldest freshwater decapod crustacean, from the Triassic of Arizona . Palaeontology . 31 . 2 . 273–279.
  137. Sidney R. Ash & Geoffrey T. Creber. 2000. The Late Araucarioxylon arizonicum Trees of the Petrified Forest National Park, Arizona, USA. Palaeontology. 43. 22–23. 10.1111/1475-4983.00116. 128691956 . free.
  138. "Vertebrate Fauna; Poposauridae; 'Chatterjeea elegans,'" Irmis (2005) p. 79|style="background:#f3e9f3;" |S. inexpectatus|style="background:#f3e9f3;" |
    • Arizona

    |style="background:#f3e9f3;" |

    • Owl Rock
    • Petrified Forest
    • Mesa Redondo

    |style="background:#f3e9f3;" ||style="background:#f3e9f3;" |Following a rediagnosis of the genus and species, only shuvosaurid fossils from the Cooper Canyon Formation are reliably identifiable as Shuvosaurus itself.[29] |-|Stenomyti|S. huangae|

    • Colorado

    |

    • "Red siltstone"

    |Partial skeleton including a well-preserved skull.|A small aetosaurine aetosaur similar to Aetosaurus.|-|Typothorax[30] |T. coccinarum|

    • Arizona

    |

    • Owl Rock
    • Petrified Forest
    • Sonsela

    |Common in the Owl Rock and Petrified Forest Members.|A large, wide-bodied typothoracine aetosaur abundant throughout the Chinle Formation. Almost all of the known Chinlean Typothorax fossils are isolated whole or fragmentary osteoderms.|-|Tecovasuchus|T. chatterjeei|

    • Arizona

    |

    • Blue Mesa

    |Osteoderms.|Previously thought to be more widespread in the formation.|-

    |Vivaron[31] |V. haydeni|

    • New Mexico

    |

    • Petrified Forest

    ||A large rauisuchid similar to Postosuchus.|-

    |}

    Ornithodirans

    Prosauropod tracks are present in the Redonda, Sloan Canyon, and Sheep Pen Sandstone formations. Possibly the Rock Point Formation as well. Geographically, the tracks are present in New Mexico.[32]

    Theropod tracks have been found in Utah and New Mexico recovered from the Redonda, Sloan Canyon, and Sheep Pen Sandstone formations. Indeterminate theropod remains are stratigraphically present in the Petrified Forest, Bluewater Creek, and Rock Point members of New Mexico.

    Ornithodirans of the Chinle Formation
    GenusSpeciesStateMemberAbundanceNotesImages
    CamposaurusC. arizonensis
    • Arizona
    • Bluewater Creek Formation
    A coelophysine coelophysid
    ChindesaurusC. bryansmalli
    • Arizona
    • Petrified Forest
    A large saurischian alternatively considered a herrerasaurid or a theropod related to Tawa hallae.
    CoelophysisC. bauri
    • "Siltstone"
    C. sp.[34]
    • Arizona
    • Petrified Forest
    Originally assigned to C. bauri, but likely a different taxon.
    C. longicollis
    • New Mexico
    • Petrified Forest
    Now considered a junior synonym of C. bauri.
    C. willistoni
    • New Mexico
    • Petrified Forest
    Now considered a junior synonym of C. bauri.
    DromomeronD. romeri
    • Arizona
    • Colorado
    • New Mexico
    • Petrified Forest (Hayden Quarry #3)
    • Owl Rock
    • ‘Red siltstone’
    A lagerpetid pterosauromorph found at various Ghost Ranch quarries and elsewhere in the Chinle Formation.
    DaemonosaurusD. chauliodus
    • New Mexico
    • "Siltstone"
    Skull and neck vertebrae fragmentsA possible basal theropod with a short skull and enlarged teeth.
    EucoelophysisE. baldwini
    • New Mexico
    • Petrified Forest
    A silesaurid dinosauriform closely related to the Polish genus Silesaurus.[35]
    Kwanasaurus[36] K. williamparkeri
    • Colorado
    • "Red siltstone"
    A silesaurid dinosauriform with adaptations for herbivory.
    TawaT. hallae
    • New Mexico
    • Petrified Forest (Hayden Quarry)
    A probable basal theropod showing a mosaic of features similar to neotheropods and herrerasaurids.

    Other Archosauromorphs

    Non-crurotarsan Archosauromorphs of the Chinle Formation
    GenusSpeciesStateMemberAbundanceNotesImages
    Crosbysaurus[37] C. harrisae
    • Arizona
    • Utah
    An archosauriform represented only by teeth. It is treated as indeterminate archosauriform remains by Irmis in 2005. It was originally thought to be an ornithischian dinosaur.
    Doswellia[38] cf. D. kaltenbachi
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa
    Osteoderms, vertebrae, rib and hip fragments.A doswelliid archosauriform.
    Puercosuchus[39] P. traverorum
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa
    Two monodominant bonebeds.A carnivorous azendohsaurid archosauromorph.
    Rugarhynchos[40] R. sixmilensis
    • New Mexico
    • Bluewater Creek
    Skull and postcranial fragments.A doswelliid archosauriform. Originally described as a species of Doswellia,[41] but subsequently transferred to a separate genus.
    Syntomiprosopus[42] S. sucherorum
    • Arizona
    Two to four individuals from a single quarry.A short-faced archosauriform, possibly an unusual early-diverging crocodylomorph. Appears convergent with some Late Cretaceous notosuchians.
    Tanystropheidae[43] Indeterminate
    • New Mexico
    • Petrified Forest
    VertebraeModerately-sized tanystropheid vertebrae from the Hayden Quarry, likely representing a new taxon closely related to Langobardisaurus and Tanytrachelos.
    Tanytrachelos[44] Indeterminate / T. ahynis
    • New Mexico
    • Arizona
    • Petrified Forest
    • Mesa Redondo
    Cervical rib, calcaneum, etc.A small tanystropheid represented by several hundred fossil specimens.
    Tecovasaurus[45] T. murryi
    • Arizona
    • Mesa Redondo
    An unknown amniote represented by scattered teeth formerly believed to be from an ornithischian dinosaur. Later discoveries of similar teeth in pseudosuchians meant that these could no longer be regarded as anything more specific than some kind of archosauriform.
    Trilophosaurus[46] T. buettneri[47]
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa
    T. dornorum[48]
    • Arizona
    • Sonsela
    T. jacobsi[49]
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa
    • Mesa Redondo
    T. phasmalophos[50]
    • Arizona
    • Sonsela
    Vancleavea[51] V. campi
    • Arizona
    • New Mexico
    A strange aquatic carnivorous archosauriform, represented by both articulated skeletons and scattered elements like osteoderms and vertebrae.

    Other amniotes

    Miscellaneous amniotes of the Chinle Formation
    GenusSpeciesStateMemberAbundanceNotesImages
    Acallosuchus[53] A. rectori
    • Arizona
    Known only from a partial skull.A strange neodiapsid whose bones were heavily ornamented "with subtriangular knobs... running the length of the bones." Even these ornamentations were ornamented "with additional grooves." It is too bizarre to be currently classified as anything more than a probable diapsid.
    Ancistronychus[54] A. paradoxus
    • Arizona
    • Sonsela
    Manual unguals (hand claws).A drepanosaur related to Drepanosaurus.
    Avicranium[55] A. renestoi
    • New Mexico
    • 'Siltstone'
    Skull and neck vertebrae.A drepanosaur with a toothless skull and a flexible neck owing to the heterocoelous (saddle-shaped) articular surfaces of the vertebral centrae. The neural spines are anteroposteriorly short and strongly anterodorsally inclined. These features closely resemble those of Drepanosaurus.
    Colognathus[56] C. obscurus
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa
    Known only from a jaw fragment and some isolated teeth.Originally believed to be a fish, Colognathus was a strange amniote with distinctive fluted teeth.
    DolabrosaurusD. aquatilis
    • New Mexico
    • Petrified Forest
    Articulated vertebral and limb material.A drepanosaur.
    Drepanosaurus[57] D. unguicaudatus
    • New Mexico
    • Petrified Forest
    A drepanosaur.
    Kataigidodon[58] K. venetus
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa
    Partial dentaries.A non-mammalian eucynodont.
    Kraterokheirodon[59] K. colberti
    • Arizona
    • Petrified Forest
    • Blue Mesa or Mesa Redondo
    Known only from two teeth.A possible cynodont. Although they share some similarities with cynodont teeth, the teeth of Kraterokheirodon are very distinctive and can't be confidently referred to a known amniote group.
    Microzemiotes[60] M. sonselaensis
    • Arizona
    • Sonsela
    Partial left dentary with three teethA diapsid reptile of uncertain affinities.
    Palacrodon[61] Indeterminate
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa
    Jaw fragments.A diapsid reptile of uncertain phylogenetic placement with unusual broadened teeth. More complete fossils of this genus from the Fremouw Formation of Antarctica suggest that it was an arboreal saurian.[62]
    Placerias[63] P. hesternus
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa
    • Mesa Redondo
    Known from several hundred remains, but very rare outside of the highly concentrated Placerias Quarry.A placeriine stahleckeriid dicynodont.
    Skybalonyx[64] S. skapter
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa
    Manual unguals (hand claws).A drepanosaur which likely had a burrowing lifestyle.
    Uatchitodon[65] U. schneideri[66]
    • Mesa Redondo
    Known in Chinle from only a single tooth. The presence of venom channels is consistent with other known Uatchitodon specimens, although the Chinle specimen's channels are unique in being "completely enclosed under the surface of the crown."A reptile of unknown affinities, probably a carnivorous archosauromorph with venomous capabilities.
    Whitakersaurus[68] W. bermani
    • New Mexico
    • "Siltstone"
    A rhynchocephalian found at Ghost Ranch.
    Indeterminate procolophonid[69] Indeterminate
    • Utah

    Amphibians

    Amphibians of the Chinle Formation
    GenusSpeciesStateMemberAbundanceNotesImages
    Apachesaurus[70] A. gregorii
    • Arizona
    Common in the Owl Rock and Petrified forest members. Blue Mesa remains are fragmentary.A metoposaurid temnospondyl which is a junior synonym of Anaschisma
    Anaschisma[71] [72] A. browni[73]
    • Arizona
    A. browni is "possibly the most common tetrapod fossil in the lower Chinle", although its presence in the upper Chinle is "unclear".A metoposaurid temnospondyl. Koskinonodon was erected for the species "Buettneria" perfecta when it was discovered that the latter genus was preoccupied. Gee et al., 2017 then synonymised it with Anaschisma.
    Chinlestegophis[74] C. jenkinsi
    • Colorado
    A temnospondyl in the group Stereospondyli, related to Rileymillerus from the Dockum Group of Texas. Possibly a stem-caecilian according to one analysis, though others have disputed this finding
    Funcusvermis[75] F. gilmorei
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa
    Numerous jaw fragments, as well as a referred maxillopalatine, vertebra, and femurA stem-caecilian
    Salientia indet.[76] Indeterminate
    • Arizona
    • Sonsela Member
    • Blue Mesa Member
    Five bones: four ilia and a partial maxilla.A stem-group frog. Might be more closely related to crown-group frogs (anurans) than to Early Triassic taxa Triadobatrachus and Czatkobatrachus.

    Cartilaginous fish

    Chondrichthyans of the Chinle Formation
    GenusSpeciesStateStratigraphic positionAbundanceNotesImages
    Acrodus[77] Indeterminate
    • Arizona
    Only a single tooth is known.A hybodontiform shark.
    Lonchidion[79] L. humblei
    • Arizona
    A hybodontiform shark. Lonchidion remains are common throughout the Carnian microvertebrate sites of the American southwest.
    PalaeoxyrisP. humblei[80]
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa
    Several specimensAn egg capsule of a freshwater hybodont shark.
    Phoebodus[81] Indeterminate
    • Arizona
    • Mesa Redondo
    Only a single specimen has been recovered from the formation.
    Reticulodus[82] R. synergus
    • Arizona
    • Owl Rock
    • Petrified Forest
    • Sonsela
    The crown of its tooth bears a "reticulating ornamentation on [its] occlusal surface[.]" Reticulodus remains are common throughout the Norian microvertebrate sites of the American southwest.
    Mooreodontus[83] [84] M. moorei
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa
    • Mesa Redondo
    Common in the lower Chinle Formation's microvertebrate localities.A xenacanthiform shark.

    Lobe-finned fish

    Lungfish

    Dipnoans (lungfish) of the Chinle Formation
    GenusSpeciesStateStratigraphic positionAbundanceNotes
    Arganodus[87] A. dorotheae
    Indeterminate
    • Arizona
    Arganodus toothplates are the most common fossil in the formation from a non-tetrapod. They are evenly distributed across strata, although some individual localities have very high concentrations.Most Chinlean Arganodus fossils are isolated tooth plates.
    CeratodusC. dorotheaeNamed by Case in 1921, in the 1980s it was referred to Arganodus.

    Ray-finned fish

    Actinopterygians (ray-finned fish) of the Chinle Formation
    GenusSpeciesStateStratigraphic positionAbundanceNotesImages
    Australosomus[88] Indeterminate[89]
    • Arizona
    • Mesa Redondo
    Known only from two vertebrae.
    Cionichthys[90] C. dunklei
    • Colorado
    • Utah
    A member of Redfieldiiformes.
    HemicalypterusH. weiri
    • Utah
    • Church Rock Member
    A member of Dapediiformes.[91]
    Lasalichthys[92] L. hillsi
    • Utah
    A member of Redfieldiiformes.
    Indeterminate[93]
    • Arizona
    Represented by isolated scales.
    Lophionotus[94] L. sanjuanensis
    • Utah
    • Church Rock Member
    A member of Semionotiformes.
    L. chinleana[95]
    • Utah
    • Church Rock Member
    A member of Semionotiformes.
    Saurichthys[96] Indeterminate
    • Arizona
    • Upper Blue Mesa Member
    A member of Saurichthyiformes.
    SynorichthysS. stewarti
    • Colorado
    • Utah
    A member of Redfieldiiformes.
    TanaocrossusT. kalliokoskii
    • Colorado
    An enigmatic actinopterygian.
    Turseodus[97] T. dolorensis
    • Colorado
    A member of Palaeonisciformes.
    Indeterminate[98]
    • Arizona
    • Owl Rock
    • Petrified Forest
    • Sonsela
    • Blue Mesa
    Common.Isolated scales from Chinle microvertebrate sites commonly have Turseodus-like ridges, however that feature is not unique to Turseodus and in 2005 Irmis advised researchers to regard them as indeterminate palaeoniscid remains.

    Plants

    The Chinle Formation has a diverse flora of plant megafossils, though they are concentrated in only a few sites with suitable conditions. One of the most diverse floral communities is found near Fort Wingate, New Mexico. Paleobotanists have traditionally placed the Fort Wingate plant beds into the Monitor Butte Member, though more recently they are placed within the Bluewater Creek Formation, a subunit of the Chinle Formation first defined in 1989.[99] Some Fort Wingate plant fossils belong to the "Lake Ciniza beds", a localized patch of grey mudstone corresponding to an ancient lake.

    Another productive areas for plant fossils is Petrified Forest National Park in Arizona. Though petrified wood could be found through the entire stratigraphy of the park, most other plant fossils are exclusive to greenish mudstone layers adjacent to the Newspaper Rock sandstone bed in the Blue Mesa Member (formerly known as the "Lower Petrified Forest").

    Conifers are the most common and diverse plants, including petrified wood and leafy branches from massive trees (Araucarioxylon, Pagiophyllum) as well as smaller shrubby forms (Pelourdea). Cycad and bennettitalean leaves and other remains make up a significant portion of the flora (Zamites, Nilssoniopteris, Williamsonia, etc.). Ferns (Cladophlebis, Phlebopteris, Clathropteris, Cynepteris, etc.) are abundant, with a range of growth habits including low shrubs, tree ferns, and palm-like fronds comparable to their modern relatives. Sphenophytes (horsetails: Neocalamites, Equistetites, Schizoneura, etc.) have low diversity but high abundance, and the largest Neocalamites fossils in the Chinle Formation could reach up to 6 meters (20 feet) in height. "Seed ferns" (Chilbinia, Marcouia?) ginkgophytes (Baiera), and small lycopods (Chinlea, Selaginella) were present but uncommon. The flora is rounded out by unusual low-growing gymnosperms such as Sanmiguelia (an angiosperm-like shrub), Dechellyia, and Dinophyton (possible relatives of Gnetales).

    The floral composition of the Chinle Formation (and other parts of Late Triassic North America) seem to shift with changes in climate over time. The lowest parts of the Chinle, such as the Shinarump Conglomerate, are dominated by the bennettitalean Eoginkgoites alongside the first occurrence of other persistent plants such as Phlebopteris, Equisetites, and most common conifer species. Subsequent subunits (such as the Blue Mesa Member, Monitor Butte Member, and Bluewater Creek Formation) are much more diverse, with a wide array of humidity-adapted plants making up the typical Chinle flora. This second floral zone is characterized by Dinophyton, a common but enigmatic shrubby gymnosperm. Plant fossils are rare in the upper part of the Chinle Formation, which was presumably much drier than the lower part. In these later layers, by far the most common plant fossils belong to Sanmiguelia (an endemic of southwestern North America) alongside conifers and horsetails.[100] [101]

    Gymnosperms

    Gymnosperms of the Chinle Formation
    GenusSpeciesStateStratigraphic positionAbundanceNotesImages
    Araucariorhiza[102] A. joae UncommonRoots of conifers similar to modern Araucariaceae. Possibly from the same plant as Araucarioxylon arizonicum.
    Araucarioxylon[104] A. arizonicum,

    A. sp.[105]

    AbundantPetrified trunks of large conifers possibly related to modern Araucariaceae.[108] State fossil of Arizona.
    AraucaritesA. rudicula[109]
    • Arizona
    • New Mexico
    • Blue Mesa
    • Monitor Butte
    Very rareLarge female conifer cones similar to those of araucariacean conifers.
    Aricycas[110] A. paulae
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    Moderately commonPinnate cycad leaves
    BaieraB. arizonica
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    • Bluewater Creek (= "lower red member", formerly Monitor Butte)
    UncommonGinkgophyte leaves
    BrachyphyllumB. sp,B. hegewaldia[112]
    • Arizona
    • New Mexico
    • Utah
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    • Agua Zarca Sandstone
    • Shinarump
    • Temple Mountain
    UncommonConifer leaves and shoots
    CarpolithusC. chinleana
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    RareSeeds of uncertain affinities
    CephalotaxopsisC. sp.
    • Arizona
    Conifer foliage
    CharmorgiaC. dijolli
    • Arizona
    • "Petrified Forest" sensu lato
    RareShort cycad stems
    Chilbinia[113] C. lichii
    • Arizona
    • Shinarump
    RareAn archaic seed fern with seeds and leaves more similar to Carboniferous-Permian seed ferns than to Triassic forms.
    CreberanthusC. bealeii
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa
    Very rarePollen-bearing cones similar to those of some extinct "pteridosperms" (seed ferns). Associated with Alisporites opii, a common palynomorph.
    DadoxylonD. chaneyi
    • Arizona
    • "Petrified Forest" sensu lato
    Very rarePossible cordaitalean conifer wood.
    Dechellyia[114] D. gormanii
    • Bluewater Creek (formerly Monitor Butte)
    • Monitor Butte
    UncommonAn enigmatic gymnosperm with narrow pinnate leaves, "clasping" leaf-like sporophylls, and winged seeds. Some leaves are affected by galls, similar to those formed by eriophyid mites in modern plants.
    DinophytonD. spinosus[117]
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    • Monitor Butte
    • Bluewater Creek ("Ciniza Lake beds", formerly Monitor Butte)
    CommonAn unusual gymnosperm combining needle-covered shoots with seed-bearing structures having the form of "pinwheel"-like clusters of tubular needles. Possibly related to Gnetales.
    ElatocladusE. puercoensis
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa
    UncommonLeaf-bearing conifer shoots
    EoginkgoitesE. sp.,E. davidsonii[119]
    • Arizona
    • Utah
    • Shinarump
    Common within its small stratigraphic rangeA bennettitalean with palm-shaped fronds similar to some ginkgo species.
    GinkgoitesG. sp.
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa
    RareA ginkgophyte
    LindleycladusL. arizonicus
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa
    UncommonConifer shoots bearing Podozamites leaves. Formerly known as Podozamites arizonicus.
    LyssoxylonL. grigsbyi
    • Arizona
    • New Mexico
    • "Petrified Forest" sensu lato
    • Bluewater Creek (formerly Monitor Butte)
    RareCycad trunks
    MarcouiaM. neuropteroides
    • Arizona
    • New Mexico
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    • Bluewater Creek (formerly Monitor Butte)
    • Monitor Butte
    UncommonFern-like gymnosperm leaves of uncertain affinities. Some leaves are affected by feeding traces including crescent-shaped marginal incisions and oval-shaped holes. These were probably produced by beetles or orthopterans (grasshoppers and kin).
    MasculostrobusM. clathratus
    • Arizona
    • Monitor Butte
    Locally commonA pollen-bearing cone associated with lattice-shaped Equisetosporites chinleana pollen.
    NilssoniopterisN. ciniza
    • Arizona
    • New Mexico
    • Utah
    • "Petrified Forest" sensu lato
    • Bluewater Creek ("Ciniza Lake beds", formerly Monitor Butte)
    • Shinarump
    UncommonLarge smooth-edged bennettitalean leaves, some of which were originally identified as Macrotaeniopteris magnifola.
    OtozamitesO. macombii
    • New Mexico
    • Agua Zarca Sandstone
    UncommonBennettitalean leaves
    PagiophyllumP. sp.,P. duttonia,

    P. navajoensis,

    P. readiana,

    P. zuniana,

    P. simpsonii[120]

    • Arizona
    • Colorado
    • New Mexico
    • "Middle Dolores"
    • "Petrified Forest" sensu lato
    • Sonsela
    • Bluewater Creek ("Ciniza Lake beds", formerly Monitor Butte)
    • Agua Zarca Sandstone
    Locally very commonConifer leaves
    PalissyaP. sp.,P. diffusa,

    P. sphenolepis

    • New Mexico
    • Utah
    • Monitor Butte
    • Agua Zarca Sandstone
    • Shinarump
    UncommonConifer leaves and shoots
    PelourdeaP. poleoensis
    • Utah
    • Colorado
    • New Mexico
    • "Siltstone"
    • "Middle Dolores"
    • Poleo
    • Bluewater Creek ("Ciniza Lake beds", formerly Monitor Butte)
    • Shinarump
    CommonA shrubby conifer with strap-like leaves arranged around a single narrow stem.
    PodozamitesP. sp.,P. emmonsi,

    P. lanceolatus

    • Arizona
    • Utah
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    • Shinarump
    • Temple Mountain
    UncommonConifer leafs and shoots
    PramelreuthiaP. dubielli,[121] P. yazzi
    • Arizona
    • New Mexico
    • Utah
    • Blue Mesa
    • Monitor Butte
    RareGymnosperm microsporophylls (pollen-bearing organs)
    PterophyllumP. sp.,P. braunianum
    • Arizona
    • Utah
    • Shinarump
    UncommonBennettitalean leaves
    SamaropsisS. sp.,S. puerca
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    UncommonSeeds of uncertain affinities
    SanmigueliaS. lewisii
    • Rock Point
    • Owl Rock
    • "Middle Dolores"
    • Petrified Forest
    • Sonsela
    • Blue Mesa
    CommonAn unusual palm-like shrub, controversially suggested to be a relative or predecessor of angiosperms (flowering plants).
    SchilderiaS. adamanica
    • Arizona
    • Petrified Forest
    RarePetrified stems of a conifer or gnetalean
    WilliamsoniaW. nizhonii[124]
    • New Mexico
    • Bluewater Creek (= "lower red member", formerly Monitor Butte)
    RareA bennettitalean "flower" (female cone)
    WoodworthiaW. arizonica
    • Arizona
    • Petrified Forest
    UncommonStems and petrified wood of a conifer related to A. arizonicum.[125]
    ZamitesZ. sp.,Z. occidentalis,

    Z. powellii

    • Church Rock?
    • Owl Rock?
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    • Sonsela
    • Bluewater Creek ("Ciniza Lake beds", formerly Monitor Butte)
    • Monitor Butte
    • Agua Zarca
    • Shinarump
    Very commonBennettitalean leaves. Some leaves exhibit feeding traces, including sharp diagonal marginal traces and slot-like non-marginal traces. These traces were probably left by beetles. Zamites powellii was formerly known as Otozamites powellii.

    Ferns

    Ferns of the Chinle Formation
    GenusSpeciesStateStratigraphic positionAbundanceNotesImages
    ApacheaA. arizonica
    • Arizona
    • "Petrified Forest"
    RareDipteridacean fern leaves, possibly damaged specimens of Clathropteris walkeri.
    CladophlebisC. daughertyi,[128] C. subfalcata,

    C. yazzia,

    C. sp.

    • Arizona
    • New Mexico
    • Utah
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    • Bluewater Creek (= "lower red member", formerly Monitor Butte)
    • Monitor Butte
    • Shinarump
    Very commonLarge sterile fern leaves of uncertain affinities
    ClathropterisC. walkeri
    • Arizona
    • New Mexico
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    • Bluewater Creek (= "lower red member", formerly Monitor Butte)
    CommonDipteridacean fern leaves
    CynepterisC. sp.,C. lasiophora
    • Utah
    • Arizona
    • New Mexico
    • Church Rock?
    • Owl Rock?
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    • Bluewater Creek (= "lower red member", formerly Monitor Butte)
    • Monitor Butte
    CommonBipinnate fern leaves previously identified as Lonchopteris. Some leaves are affected by crescent-shaped marginal feeding traces, probably from beetles or orthopterans (grasshoppers and kin).
    Itopsidema[129] I. vancleavi
    • Arizona
    • Sonsela
    UncommonStems of large osmundacean tree ferns. Some stems show evidence of being bored by oribatid mites.[130]
    PhlebopterisP. smithii,P. utensis
    • Arizona[131]
    • New Mexico
    • Utah
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    • Bluewater Creek (= "lower red member" / "Ciniza Lake beds", formerly Monitor Butte)
    • Shinarump
    CommonMatoniacean fern leaves with a palmate structure
    SphenopterisS. arizonica
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    UncommonSterile fern leaves of uncertain affinities. Some show evidence for marginal damage by insect feeding traces.
    ToditesT. fragilis
    • Arizona
    • New Mexico
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    • Bluewater Creek (="lower red member", formerly Monitor Butte)
    UncommonOsmundacean fern leaves
    WingateaW. plumosa
    • Arizona
    • New Mexico
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    • Bluewater Creek (="lower red member", formerly Monitor Butte)
    RareGleicheniacean fern leaves previously named as a species of Coniopteris.

    Other plants

    Other plants of the Chinle Formation
    GenusSpeciesStateStratigraphic positionAbundanceNotesImages
    ChinleaC. sp.,C. campii
    • "Petrified Forest" sensu lato
    UncommonSmall lycopod stems similar to shrubby forms such as Pleuromeia.
    EquisetitesE. sp.,E. bradyi
    • Arizona
    • Utah
    • New Mexico
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    • Bluewater Creek ("Ciniza Lake beds", formerly Monitor Butte)
    • Shinarump
    CommonA horsetail indistinguishable from modern Equisetum.
    Equisetocalis[134] E. muirii
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa
    Concentrated in a narrow stratigraphic range (the Newspaper Rock sandstone bed)Small three-dimensional horsetail stems preserved in pyrite nodules.
    IsoetitesI. circularis
    • Arizona
    • "Petrified Forest" sensu lato
    RareQuillwort shoots
    LycostrobusL. chinleana
    • Arizona
    • Blue Mesa (= "Lower Petrified Forest")
    RareHorsetail cones sometimes placed in the genus Equicalostrobus
    NeocalamitesN. sp.,N. virginiensis
    • Arizona
    • Utah
    • Colorado[135]
    • New Mexico
    • "Siltstone"
    • Church Rock?
    • Owl Rock?
    • "Petrified Forest" sensu lato
    • Bluewater Creek (= "lower red member" / "Ciniza Lake beds", formerly Monitor Butte)
    CommonStems and leaves of a giant sphenophyte (horsetail)
    SchizoneuraS. harrisii
    • New Mexico
    • Bluewater Creek (formerly Monitor Butte)
    UncommonStems and leaves of a large sphenophyte (horsetail) more typical of Southern Hemisphere plant assemblages.
    SelaginellaS. anasazia
    • Arizona
    • Monitor Butte
    UncommonA low-growing lycopsid similar to modern broad-leaved species of Selaginella, such as S. kraussiana

    Arthropods

    Arthropods of the Chinle Formation
    GenusSpeciesStateStratigraphic positionAbundanceNotesImages
    EnoplocytiaE. porteri[136]
    • Arizona
    • Sonsela?
    Single well-preserved fossilAn erymid crayfish
    Paleoscolytus[137] P. divergus
    • Arizona
    • Sonsela
    A species of bark beetle, evidenced by trace fossils of tracks made on A. arizonicum specimens.

    Bibliography

    • Irmis, R. B. 2005. The vertebrate fauna of the Upper Triassic Chinle Formation in northern Arizona. p. 63-88. in S.J. Nesbitt, W.G. Parker, and R.B. Irmis (eds.) 2005. Guidebook to the Triassic formations of the Colorado Plateau in northern Arizona: Geology, Paleontology, and History. Mesa Southwest Museum Bulletin 9.
    • Mueller, B. D. and Parker, W. G. 2006. A new species of Trilophosaurus (Diapsida: Archosauromorpha) from the Sonsela Member (Chinle Formation) of Petrified Forest National Park, Arizona. In W. G. Parker, S. R. Ash & R. B. Irmis (eds.), A Century of Research at Petrified Forest National Park, 1906-2006: Geology and Paleontology. Museum of Northern Arizona Bulletin 62:119-125
    • Mueller, B.D.. 2007. Koskinonodon Branson and Mehl, 1929, a replacement name for the preoccupied temnospondyl Buettneria Case, 1922. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 27. 1. 225. 10.1671/0272-4634(2007)27[225:KBAMAR]2.0.CO;2. 85763026.
    • Weishampel, David B.; Dodson, Peter; and Osmólska, Halszka (eds.): The Dinosauria, 2nd, Berkeley: University of California Press. 861 pp. .
  139. "Vertebrate Fauna; 'Rauisuchidae'; 'Saurosuchus sp.,'" Irmis (2005) p. 78|style="background:#f3e9f3;" |Indeterminate|style="background:#f3e9f3;" |
    • Arizona

    |style="background:#f3e9f3;" |

    • Blue Mesa

    |style="background:#f3e9f3;" |Jaw fragment.|style="background:#f3e9f3;" |Identified from a fossil which has been reinterpreted as an indeterminate "rauisuchian".|-|Scutarx[28] |S. deltatylus|

    • Arizona

    |

    • Sonsela

    |Four partial skeletons including skull fragments.|A large basal desmatosuchine aetosaur based on fossils originally referred to "Stagonolepis" (=Calyptosuchus) wellesi, a close relative. Fossils of Scutarx represent the highest stratigraphic occurrence of Stagonolepis-like aetosaurs in Petrified Forest National Park.|-

    |style="background:#f3e9f3;" |Shuvosaurus[29]

  140. "Vertebrate Fauna; Crocodylomorpha; 'Parrishia mccreai,'" Irmis (2005) pp. 80-81|P. mccreai|
    • Arizona

    |

    • Blue Mesa
    • Mesa Redondo

    | An early-diverging crocodylomorph| |-|Poposaurus[22] |P. gracilis|

    • Arizona

    |

    • Blue Mesa
    • Mesa Redondo

    ||-|Postosuchus[23] |P. kirkpatricki|

    • Arizona

    |

    • Owl Rock
    • Petrified Forest
    • Sonsela
    • Blue Mesa
    • Mesa Redondo

    |||-

    | rowspan="2" |Revueltosaurus[24] |R. callenderi[25] |

    • Arizona

    |

    • Petrified Forest

    |||-|R. hunti[26] |

    • Arizona

    |

    • Blue Mesa

    |||-|Rioarribasuchus|R. chamaensis|

    • Arizona[27]
    • New Mexico

    |

    • Petrified Forest
    • Sonsela

    |Osteoderms and possible ankle and vertebrae remains.|A late-surviving paratypothoracin typothoracine aetosaur. Originally referred to Desmatosuchus, but later reinterpreted as a relative of Paratypothorax based on a phylogenetic analysis performed on the remains by Parker in 2003. New genus names were erected independently by Parker (coining the name Heliocanthus) and Lucas et al. (coining the name Rioarribasuchus), prompting an investigation into reports of unethical taxonomic claim-jumping.|-|Saurosuchus[28]