Including players from the Parramatta Eels and Parramatta Eels Women that have represented while at the club and the years they achieved their honours, if known. Representatives from the Wentworthville Magpies and Cabramatta Two-Blues are included as they are feeder clubs.
Ian Johnston (1949) Harold Crocker (1954–55) Ron Boden (1960) Bill Rayner (1960) Ron Lynch (1961–62, 1966–67, 1970) Brian Hambly (1963–65) Ken Thornett (1963–64) Dick Thornett (1963–64, 1966, 1968) Barry Rushworth (1964) Bob O'Reilly (1970–74) Keith Campbell (1971) Ray Higgs (1975, 1977) Denis Fitzgerald (1975, 1977) John Quayle (1975) Jim Porter (1975) Michael Cronin (1977–82) John Peard (1977) John Kolc (1977) Graham Olling (1978) Ray Price (1978–84) Neville Glover (1978) Geoff Gerard (1978) Ron Hilditch (1978, 1981) Garry Dowling (1980) John Muggleton (1982) Brett Kenny (1982, 1984, 1986–87) Steve Ella (1982–83, 1985) Eric Grothe, Sr. (1982–84) Peter Sterling (1982–83, 1986–88) Peter Wynn (1985) Bob Lindner (1987–88) Jim Dymock (1996) John Simon (1997) Dean Pay (1998) Jason Smith (1998–00) Michael Vella (1999-01) Nathan Hindmarsh (2000, 2004–07, 2009) Jamie Lyon (2001, 2003) Timana Tahu (2005–06) Eric Grothe, Jr. (2005) Jarryd Hayne (2007, 2009–10, 2013–14) Semi Radradra (2016) Reagan Campbell-Gillard (2022) Mitchell Moses (2024)
Mark Horo (1990) Jarrod McCracken (1998–99) Nathan Cayless (1998-01, 2003–08) David Kidwell (1999–00) David Vaealiki (2000–03) David Solomona (2001–02) Krisnan Inu (2007–08) Fuifui Moimoi (2007, 2009, 2011) Manu Ma'u (2016) Brad Takairangi (2017) Marata Niukore (2022) Dylan Brown (2022–23) Isaiah Papali'i (2022) Jarrod McCracken (1997)
Apirana Pewhairangi (2013)
Dean Parata (2013) Nathan Brown (2017, 2022) Daniel Alvaro (2017) Nick Okladnikov (2018) Luca Moretti (2022) Jack Colovatti (2022)
Mark Daoud (2014) Tim Mannah (2017) Mitch Moses (2017, 2022) Anthony Layoun (2017) Elie El-Zakhem (2022) Jabriel Kalache (2022)
Kevin Prior (2007–08) Richard Kambo (2009)
Marata Niukore (2017, 2019) Brad Takairangi (2019) Tepai Moeroa (2019) Makahesi Makatoa (2022–24)
Kaleveti Naisoro (1995) Jarryd Hayne (2008, 2018) Lepani Waqa (2009) Donas Gock (2009-2011) Semi Radradra (2013–14) Fabian Goodall (2014–15) Salesi Faingaa (2017) Kane Evans (2018–19) Maika Sivo (2019, 2022–24) Waqa Blake (2022–23)
Ben Roberts (2013) Reni Maitua (2013) Kaysa Pritchard (2016–17) Junior Paulo (2016, 2019, 2022–2023) Suaia Matagi (2017) Frank Pritchard (2017) Oregon Kaufusi (2022) Daejarn Asi (2023) Blaize Talagi (2024) Jake Tago (2024)
Phil Howlett (1995) Feleti Mateo (2006, 2008–10) Etu Uaisele (2006, 2008-09) Fuifui Moimoi (2006, 2013) Tony Williams (2008) Taniela Lasalo (2008) Kim Uasi (2009) Peni Terepo (2013–19) Vai Toutai (2014, 2016) John Folau (2014) Richard Fa'aoso (2015) Manu Ma'u (2015, 2017–19) Siosaia Vave (2017) Michael Jennings (2017–19) Will Penisini (2022–23)
Matthew Petersen (2004) Joseph Paulo (2010–13) Bureta Faraimo (2013) Simaima Taufa (2022) Kennedy Cherrington (2022–23) Mahalia Murphy (2024) Capri Paekau (2023) Lindsay Tui (2023–24) Pihuka Berryman-Duff (2023–24) Tafao Asaua (2023) Cassey Tohi-Hiku (2023–24) Amelia Mafi (2023) Jade Fonua (2023–24) Shannon Muru (2023) Kate Fallon (2024) Elsie Albert (2024) Chelsea Makira (2024) Tahleisha Maeva (2024) Ryvrr-Lee Alo (2024) Jarryd Hayne (2010, 2013) Nathan Hindmarsh (2011–12) Joseph Paulo (2015) Semi Radradra (2016) Beau Scott (2016) Tepai Moeroa (2017) Nathan Hindmarsh (2005, 2008, 2011) Brett Finch (2005) Jarryd Hayne (2006, 2008) Ben Smith (2010) Tim Mannah (2011) Luke Burt (2011) Semi Radradra (2016) Corey Norman (2017) Nathan Brown (2019) Clinton Gutherson (2019) Reed Mahoney (2019) Mitchell Moses (2019) Sean Russell (2024) Kennedy Cherrington (2023) Rueben Cherrington (2023) Abbi Church (2023-24) Kimberley Hunt (2023) Rachael Pearson (2023) Taneka Todhunter (2023) Cassey Tohi-Hiku (2023) Rory Owen (2024) Nathan Cayless (2008) Krisnan Inu (2008) David Kidwell (2000) Weller Hauraki (2008)New Zealand
Nathan Cayless (2008)Italy
Nathan Brown (2022)Lebanon
Mitch Moses (2022)Samoa
Frank Pritchard (2017) Junior Paulo (2022)----
New Zealand
Jarrod McCracken (1999) Nathan Cayless (2001, 2004, 2006, 2008)Samoa
Junior Paulo (2023)Tonga
Fuifui Moimoi (2006) Feleti Mateo (2010)----
NSW Country
Italy
Nathan Brown (2022)Lebanon
Mitch Moses (2017, 2022)Fiji
Jarryd Hayne (2008)Tonga
Fuifui Moimoi (2013)United States
Joseph Paulo (2013)----
New South Wales
Australia
Vic Hey (Coach – 1950–51) Terry Fearnley (Coach – 1977)Cook Islands
David Fairleigh (Coach – 2009)New Zealand
Stephen Kearney (Coach – 2011–12)----
NSW City
NSW Country