Angels in Islam explained

In Islam, angels (ar|{{Script|Arab|ملاك٬ ملك; plural: ar|{{Script|Arab|ملائِكة or fa|فرشته|''ferešte'') are believed to be heavenly beings, created from a luminous origin by God.[1] [2] [3] [4] The Quran is the principal source for the Islamic concept of angels, but more extensive features of angels appear in hadith literature, literature, Islamic exegesis, theology, philosophy, and mysticism.[3] [4] [5] Generally, belief in angels is one of the core tenets within Islam, as it is one of the six articles of faith.[6] Angels are more prominent in Islam compared to Judeo-Christian tradition.[7] The angels differ from other invisible creatures in their attitude as creatures of virtue, in contrast to evil devils (ar|شَيَاطِين|''šayāṭīn'' or fa|دیو|''dīv'') and ambiguous jinn (ar|جِنّ or fa|پَری|''parī'').[8] [3] [9] [10] Despite being considered to be virtuous beings, angels are not necessarily bringers of good news, as per Islamic tradition, angels can perform grim and violent tasks.[11]

Angels are conceptualized as heavenly beings. As such, they are said to lack passion and bodily desires. If angels can nevertheless fail, is debated in Islam. Contemporary Salafis usually hold the opinion that angels are always obedient and never fail to perform their tasks. In contrast, schools of theology (Kalām) often accept the fallibility of angels. Māturīdites say that the heavenly creatures are tested, and angels may fail such a test, whereupon they are dismissed from their duties. Some Ashʿarite likewise argue that angels can fail, but have no free-will. In contrast, most Mu'tazilites, including some Asharis such as al-Razi, consider angels to lack free-will and being infallible.

In Islamic philosophy and Sufism, angels are related to the nature of reason (aql). According to Sufi cosmology, they connect the higher realms of the intellect with the lower world of matter. Thus, the human mind is conceptualized to form a connection with the heavenly spheres (malakūt) through such heavenly entities associated with (nūr). In contrast, the devils attempt to disturb the connection by diverging the mind to the lower spheres, thus associated with fire (nār).

Etymology

The Quranic word for angel (ar|ملك|malak|links=no) derives either from, meaning "he controlled", due to their power to govern different affairs assigned to them,[12] or from the triliteral root, or with the broad meaning of a "messenger", just as its counterpart in Hebrew . Unlike the Hebrew word, however, the term is used exclusively for heavenly spirits of the divine world, as opposed to human messengers. The Quran refers to both angelic and human messengers as instead.[13]

Characteristics

In Islam, angels are heavenly creatures created by God. They are considered older than humans and jinn.[14] Although Muslim authors disagree on the exact nature of angels, they agree that they are autonomous entities with subtle bodies.[15] Yet, both concepts of angels as anthropomorphic creatures with wings and as abstract forces are acknowledged.[16] Angels play an important role in Muslim everyday life by protecting the believers from evil influences and recording the deeds of humans. They have different duties, including their praise of God, interacting with humans in ordinary life, defending against devils (shayāṭīn) and carrying on natural phenomena.[4]

In Islamic philosophy angelic qualities, just as devilish ones, are assumed to be part of human's nature, the angelic one related to the spirit (ruh) and reason (aql), while the devilish one to egoism.[17] Angels might accompany aspiring saints or advise pious humans.

One of the Islamic major characteristic is their lack of bodily desires; they never get tired, do not eat or drink, and have no anger.[18] Various Islamic scholars such as Ibn Kathir, Ibn Taymiyya, Al-Tabari, Fakhr al-Din al-Razi, and Umar Sulaiman Al-Ashqar also quoted that angels do not need to consume food or drinks.[19] They are also described as immortal, unlike jinn. In Islamic traditions, they are described as being created from incorporeal light or fire .[20] [21] Ahmad Sirhindi, a 17th-century Indian scholar, has added, that angels can take various shapes.[22]

Purity

Angels believed to be engaged in human affairs are closely related to Islamic purity and modesty rituals. Many hadiths, including Muwatta Imam Malik from one of the Kutub al-Sittah, talk about angels being repelled by humans' state of impurity.[23] It is argued that if driven away by ritual impurity, the Kiraman Katibin, who record people's actions,[23] and the guardian angel,[23] will not perform their tasks assigned to the individual. Another hadith specifies, during the state of impurity, bad actions are still written down, but good actions are not.

When a person tells a lie, angels nearby are separated from the person from the stench the lie emanates.[23] Angels also depart from humans when they are naked or are having a bath out of decency, but also curse people who are nude in public.[23] Ahmad Sirhindi has mentioned that the angels nobility are because their substances are created from luminous light.

Angels are believed to be attracted to clean and sacred places. Impure conditions, such as dogs or unclean places, may impede an angels' duty.[24] [25] [26] [27]

Obedience

The possibility and degree of angels errability is debated in Islam.[28] Hasan of Basra (d. 728) is often considered one of the first who asserted the doctrine of angelic infallibility. When discussing the nature of Iblis, Tabari does not mention angelic infallibility, the idea might not have been universal in early Islam.[29] Thus, from the traditions of ibn Abbas (angels can sin) and Hasan of Basra (angels cannot sin) two different opinions derived. In a comment by Gibril Haddad on Qadi Baydawi's defense on angelic fallibility in his Tafsir al-Baydawi it is said that the angels' "obedience is their nature while their disobedience is a burden, while human beings' obedience is a burden and their hankering after lust is their nature."[15]

Infallible

Opposition to the concept of the fallen angel is mostly found among the Qadariyah and most Mu'tazilites.[30] Many Salafis also agree with this view.[31] Those who oppose angelic fallibility refer to Surah at-Tahrim (66:6)[32] in favor of their position:

O believers! Protect yourselves and your families from a Fire whose fuel is people and stones, overseen by formidable and severe angels, who never disobey whatever Allah orders—always doing as commanded.

Fakhr al-Din al-Razi is an exception to most mutakallimūn, and agrees that angels are free from any form of sin and includes angelic infallibility to the six articles of faith.[33] Al-Razi argues that "except Iblis" (2:34, 18:50) is read as an "uninterupted exception" (istithna munqathi), excluding Iblis from the group of angels and states that he hailed from jinn species instead.[34] Ibn Taimiyya rejects any ambiguity on the nature of Iblis and portrays him as a satanic jinni in contrast to the angels.[35] Following the opinions of ibn Taimiyya and his disciple ibn Kathir, many scholars of Salafism and Wahhabism agree on this.[36] Furthermore, many of them regard this as a major difference between Christianity and Islam.[37]

Fallible

Surah 2:30 portrays the angels arguing with God about the creation of Adam, since Adam's progeny will cause suffering. From among the angels, Iblis refuses to pay homage to Adam and is banned. The phrase "except Iblis" in 2:34 and 18:50 is understood as an uninterupted exception (istithna' muttasil).[38] A possible reconciliation of Iblis' fall and the doctrine of angelic impeccability is to say that God wanted Iblis to disobey[39] [40] or that Iblis' disobedience derives from noble yet misguided motivation.[41]

Al-Maturidi (853–944 CE) rejects that angels are free from sin altogether, stating that angels too are tested and also have free-will based on the Quran:[42] [43]

By calling the stars adornment of the heavens, we can deduce another meaning: that is, the inhabitants of the heavens themselves are put to the test to see which of them is the best in deeds, (...)

Those who are in support of the concept of fallen angels (including Tabari, Suyuti, al-Nasafi, and al-Māturīdī) refer to al-Anbiya (21:29) stating that angels would be punished for sins and arguing that, if angels could not sin, they would not be warned to refrain from commiting them:[44] [45]

Whoever of them were to say, "I am a god besides Him", they would be rewarded with Hell by Us [...]

Besides the case of Iblis, the presence of Harut and Marut in the Quran, further hindered their complete absolution from potentially sinning.[15] [46] Although not explicit in the Quran, some exegetes linked them to Iblis, and the angels with him, protesting the creation of Adam.[47]

Sufism

Just as in non-Sufi-related traditions, angels are thought of as created of light. Al-Jili specifies that the angels are created from the Light of Muhammad and in his attribute of guidance, light and beauty.[48] Influenced by Ibn Arabi's Sufi metaphysics, Haydar Amuli identifies angels as created to represent different names/attributes of God's beauty, while the devils are created in accordance with God's attributes of Majesty, such as "The Haughty" or "The Domineering".[49]

Andalusian scholar ibn Arabi argues that a human generally ranks below angels, but developed to al-Insān al-Kāmil, ranks above them. While most earlier Sufis (like Hasan al-Basri) advised their disciples to imitate the angels, Ibn-Arabi advised them to surpass the angels. The angels being merely a reflection of the Divine Names in accordance within the spiritual realm, humans experience the Names of God manifested both in the spiritual and in the material world.[50] [51] This reflects the major opinion that prophets and messengers among humans rank above angels, but the ordinary human below an angel, while the messengers among angels rank higher than prophets and messengers among humans.[52] Ibn Arabi elaborates his ranking in based on a report by Tirmidhi. Accordingly, Muhammad intercedes for the angels first, then for (other) prophets, saints, believers, animals, plants and inanimate objects last, this explaining the hierarchy of beings in general Muslim thought.[53]

In Sufism, angels do not appear as merely models for the mystic but also their companions. Humans, in a state between earth and heaven, seek angels as guidance to reach the upper realms.[50] Some authors have suggested that some individual angels in the microcosmos represent specific human faculties on a macrocosmic level.[54] According to a common belief, if a Sufi can not find a sheikh to teach him, he will be taught by the angel Khidr.[55] [56] The presence of an angel depends on human's obedience to divine law. Dirt, depraved morality and desecration may ward off an angel.[50] A saint might be given the ability to see angels as gift (karāmāt) from God.[57]

Ahmad al-Tijani, founder of the Tijaniyyah order, narrates that angels are created through the words of humans. Through good words an angel of mercy is created, but through evil words an angel of punishment is created. By God's degree, if someone repents from evil words, the angel of punishment may turn into an angel of mercy.[58]

Philosophy (Falsafa)

Muslim philosophers, such as al-Fārābī and Ibn Sīnā, drew from Aristotelianism and Neo-Platonism a hierarchy of causal effects. God created the divine Intellect known from Aristotelian cosmology[59] [60] and the writings of Plotinus, identified with an angel (usually Gabriel). The archangel then influences other cosmic intellects who in turn influence the sublunary world.[61] [62] [63] [64]

Muslim theologians (mutakallimun), for example al-Suyuti[65] and al-Taftazani,[66] generally rejected the philosophical depiction of angels as immaterial beings, since angels are, according to ḥadīṯ, created from light .[67] In response to the invisibility of angels, Taftazani argues that only God is immaterial and that angels evade perception due to their transparent bodies.[68]

The influential Sunni Muslim author al-Ghazali (–19 December 1111) reconciled the Islamic Neo-Platonist with traditional Sufi interpretations.[69] [70] He divides human nature into four domains, each representing another type of creature: animals, beasts, devils and angels.[71] [72] [73] The spiritual components are related to, the plane in which symbols take on form, angels and devils advise the human hearth .[74]

Notes and References

  1. Encyclopedia: Webb . Gisela . Gisela Webb . 2006 . Angel . McAuliffe . Jane Dammen . Jane Dammen McAuliffe . . I . . . 10.1163/1875-3922_q3_EQCOM_00010 . 90-04-14743-8.
  2. MacDonald, D.B. and Madelung, W., "Malāʾika", in: Encyclopaedia of Islam, Second Edition, Edited by: P. Bearman, Th. Bianquis, C.E. Bosworth, E. van Donzel, W.P. Heinrichs. Online, retrieved 4 January 2024 Erste Online-Publikation: 2012Erste Druckedition: ISBN 9789004161214, 1960-2007
  3. Encyclopedia: Reynolds . Gabriel S. . Gabriel Said Reynolds . 2009 . Angels . Fleet . Kate . Krämer . Gudrun . Gudrun Krämer . Matringe . Denis . Nawas . John . Rowson . Everett K. . Everett K. Rowson . . 3 . . . 10.1163/1573-3912_ei3_COM_23204 . 978-90-04-18130-4 . 1873-9830.
  4. Kassim . Husain . 2007 . Nothing can be Known or Done without the Involvement of Angels: Angels and Angelology in Islam and Islamic Literature . Beentjes . Pancratius C. . Liesen . Jan . Deuterocanonical and Cognate Literature Yearbook . 2007 . 2007 . . . 645–662 . 10.1515/9783110192957.6.645 . 1614-337X . 201096692.
  5. Stephen Burge Angels in Islam: Jalal al-Din al-Suyuti's al-Haba'ik fi akhbar al-mala'ik Routledge 2015 p. 22-23
  6. Web site: BBC – Religions – Islam: Basic articles of faith. https://web.archive.org/web/20180813005904/http://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/islam/beliefs/beliefs.shtml. 13 August 2018. live. 2018-08-13.
  7. Kiel, Micah D. The Catholic Biblical Quarterly, vol. 71, no. 1, 2009, pp. 215–18. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/43726529. Accessed 21 February 2023.
  8. (Mahmoud Omidsalar) Originally Published: December 15, 2000 Last Updated: February 7, 2012 This article is available in print. Vol. X, Fasc. 4, pp. 418-422
  9. Book: el-Zein, Amira . 2009 . Correspondences Between Jinn and Humans . https://books.google.com/books?id=JjTctEZXHCQC&pg=PA20 . Islam, Arabs, and Intelligent World of the Jinn . . . Contemporary Issues in the Middle East . 20 . 978-0-8156-5070-6 . j.ctt1j5d836.5 . 2009026745 . 785782984.
  10. Reynolds, Gabriel Said, "Angels", in: Encyclopaedia of Islam, THREE, Edited by: Kate Fleet, Gudrun Krämer, Denis Matringe, John Nawas, Devin J. Stewart. Consulted online on 02 January 2024 First published online: 2009First print edition: 9789004181304, 2009, 2009-3
  11. Yazaki, Saeko. "Classes of Beings in Sufism." Sufi Cosmology. Brill, 2022. 68-88.
  12. Ali, Syed Anwer. [1984] 2010. Qurʼan, the Fundamental Law of Human Life: Surat ul-Faateha to Surat-ul-Baqarah (sections 1–21). Syed Publications. p. 121.
  13. Burge . Stephan R. . 2011 . The Angels in Sūrat al-Malāʾika: Exegeses of . . 10 . 1 . 50–70. 10.3366/E1465359109000230.
  14. Kuehn, Sara, Stefan Leder, and Hans-Peter Pökel. The intermediate worlds of angels: Islamic representations of celestial beings in transcultural contexts. Orient-Institut, 2019. p. 336
  15. Book: ibn ʿUmar al-Baydawi, ʿAbd Allah . Gibril Fouad . Haddad . 2016 . The Lights Of Revelation And The Secrets Of Interpretation . Beacon Books and Media Limited . 978-0-9926335-7-8.
  16. Book: Burge . Stephen . 2015 . 2012 . Part 1: Angels, Islam, and al-Suyūṭī's Al-Ḥabāʾik fī akhbār al-malāʾik – Angels in Classical Islam and contemporary scholarship . https://books.google.com/books?id=ZzVACwAAQBAJ&pg=PA3 . Angels in Islam: Jalāl al-Dīn al-Suyūṭī's Al-Ḥabāʾik fī akhbār al-malāʾik . . . 1st . 3–15 . 10.4324/9780203144978 . 978-0-203-14497-8 . 2011027021 . 933442177 . 169825282.
  17. Web site: Meleklere 陌man 禄 Sorularla 陌slamiyet . 24 June 2008.
  18. Book: Glassé . Cyril . Smith . Huston . The New Encyclopedia of Islam . 2003 . Rowland Altamira . 978-0-759-10190-6 . 49–50.
  19. Web site: h Muhammad Singgih Pamungkas . Mengenal Alam Malaikat (1) . muslim.or.id . Al-Atsari Islamic Education Foundation /Kantor Sekretariat Yayasan Pendidikan Islam Al-Atsari (YPIA) . 21 December 2023 . Id . 15 December 2022 . Dr. Sulaiman Al Asyqor, 'Alamul Malaikat, hal. 18.
  20. Kuehn, Sara. "The Primordial Cycle Revisited: Adam, Eve, and the Celestial Beings." The intermediate worlds of angels (2019): 173-199.
  21. Jane Dammen McAuliffe Encyclopaedia of the Qurʾān Volume 3 Georgetown University, Washington DC p. 45
  22. Book: Ahmed Sirhindi Faruqi . Maktubat Imam Rabbani (Shaykh Ahmed Sirhindi) . 22 November 2023 . En, Pa . 31 - INFORMATION ABOUT GENIES. https://web.archive.org/web/20090810170341/http://www.maktabah.org/index.php/sufism/45-maktubat/62-maktubat-imam-rabbani.html . 2009-08-10.
  23. Burge . Stephen R. . January 2010 . Impurity / Danger! . Islamic Law and Society . . . 17 . 3–4 . 320–349 . 10.1163/156851910X489869 . 0928-9380 . 23034917.
  24. Sa'diyya Shaikh Sufi Narratives of Intimacy: Ibn Arabi, Gender, and Sexuality Univ of North Carolina Press 2012 page 114
  25. Christian Krokus The Theology of Louis Massignon CUA Press 2017 page 89
  26. Web site: Melekler akıllı varlıklardır – Dinimiz İslam. dinimiz. islam. dinimizislam.com. (Turkish)
  27. https://sorularlarisale.com/melekler-gunahsiz-degil-mi-onlarda-kotu-haslet-ve-hasiyetler-olur-mu-imtihana-tabi-tutulurlar-mi-hz-adem-seytani-orada (Turkish)
  28. Welch, Alford T. (2008) Studies in Qur'an and Tafsir. Riga, Latvia: Scholars Press. p. 756.
  29. Erdağı, D. Evil in Turkish Muslim horror film: the demonic in "Semum". SN Soc Sci 4, 27 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s43545-024-00832-w
  30. Basharin, Pavel V. (April 1, 2018). "The Problem of Free Will and Predestination in the Light of Satan's Justification in Early Sufism". English Language Notes. 56 (1). Durham, North Carolina: Duke University Press: 119–138. doi:10.1215/00138282-4337480. S2CID 165366613.
  31. Gauvain, Richard (2013). Salafi Ritual Purity: In the Presence of God. Abingdon, England: Routledge. ISBN 978-0710313560 p. 73
  32. Hoffman, Valerie J. The Essentials of Ibadi Islam. Syracuse University Press, 2012. p. 188
  33. Street, Tony. "Medieval Islamic doctrine on the angels: the writings of Fakhr al-Dīh al-Rāzī." Parergon 9.2 (1991): 111-127.
  34. Teuma, E. (1980). The nature of" Iblis" in the Qur’an as interpreted by the commentators. p. 14
  35. Sela, R., Sartori, P., & DeWeese, D. (Eds.). (2022). Muslim Religious Authority in Central Eurasia (Vol. 43). Brill. p. 78
  36. Sela, R., Sartori, P., & DeWeese, D. (Eds.). (2022). Muslim Religious Authority in Central Eurasia (Vol. 43). Brill. p. 81
  37. Sela, R., Sartori, P., & DeWeese, D. (Eds.). (2022). Muslim Religious Authority in Central Eurasia (Vol. 43). Brill. p. 78
  38. Teuma, E. (1980). The nature of "Iblis" in the Qur’an as interpreted by the commentators p. 14
  39. Abu-Zaid, Nasr. "The Perfect Man in Islam: A Textual Analysis." 大阪外国語大学学報 77 (1989): 123-124.
  40. Öztürk, Mustafa. "The Tragic Story of Iblis (Satan) in the Qur’an." Journal of Islamic Research 2.2 (2009): 139
  41. Cole, Juan. "Infidel or Paganus? The Polysemy of kafara in the Quran." JAOS 140.3 (2020): 615-636.
  42. Ulrich Rudolph Al-Māturīdī und Die Sunnitische Theologie in Samarkand Brill, 1997 ISBN 978-90-04-10023-7 pp. 54-56
  43. Saleh, Walid A. "Rereading al-Ṭabarī through al-Māturīdī: New light on the third century hijrī." Journal of Qur'anic Studies 18.2 (2016): 180-209.
  44. Ulrich Rudolph Al-Māturīdī und Die Sunnitische Theologie in Samarkand Brill, 1997 ISBN 978-90-04-10023-7 pp. 54-56
  45. Yüksek Lisans Tezi Imam Maturidi'nin Te'vilatu'l-kur'an'da gaybi konulara İstanbul-2020 2501171277
  46. MacDonald, D.B. and Madelung, W., "Malāʾika", in: Encyclopaedia of Islam, Second Edition, Edited by: P. Bearman, Th. Bianquis, C.E. Bosworth, E. van Donzel, W.P. Heinrichs. Consulted online on 12 October 2021 First published online: 2012First print edition:, 1960-2007
  47. Ayoub, Mahmoud M. Qurʾan and Its Interpreters, The, Volume 1 State University of New York Press, 30.06.1984 p. 131
  48. Awn, Peter J. (1983). Satan's Tragedy and Redemption: Iblīs in Sufi Psychology. Leiden, Germany: Brill Publishers. p. 182
  49. Ayman Shihadeh Sufism and Theology Edinburgh University Press, 21 November 2007 pp. 54-56
  50. Reynolds, Gabriel Said, "Angels", in: Encyclopaedia of Islam, THREE, Edited by: Kate Fleet, Gudrun Krämer, Denis Matringe, John Nawas, Everett Rowson. Consulted online on 17 August 2021 First published online: 2009 First print edition: 9789004181304, 2009, 2009-3
  51. Mohamed Haj Yousef The Single Monad Model of the Cosmos: Ibn Arabi's Concept of Time and Creation ibnalarabi 2014 page 292
  52. Houtsma, M. Th. (1993). E.J. Brill's First Encyclopaedia of Islam, 1913–1936, Band 5. Brill. p. 191. ISBN 978-9-004-09791-9 p. 191
  53. Gallorini, Louise. The Symbolic Functions of Angels in the Qur'an and Sufi Literature. Diss. 2021. p. 304
  54. John Renard Historical Dictionary of Sufism Rowman & Littlefield, 19 November 2015 p. 38
  55. Michael Anthony Sells Early Islamic Mysticism (CWS) Paulist Press 1996 page 39
  56. Noel Cobb Archetypal Imagination: Glimpses of the Gods in Life and Art SteinerBooks page 194
  57. Maddenin bu bölümü TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi'nin 2022 yılında Ankara'da basılan 25. cildinde, 265-268 numaralı sayfalarda "KERÂMET" başlığıyla yer almıştır. Matbu nüshayı pdf dosyası olarak indirmek için tıklayınız. Bu bölüm en son 13.02.2019 tarihinde güncellenmiştir
  58. Wright, Zachary Valentine. "Realizing Islam, Sustainable History Monograph Pilot OA."
  59. Efremova, Natalia V. "The Islamization of Aristotelism in the Metaphysics of Ibn Sina." RUDN Journal of Philosophy 24.1 (2020): 20
  60. Webb, Geoffrey. “Aristotle and the Angels: Convergence of Islam and Christianity.” Studies: An Irish Quarterly Review 79, no. 315 (1990): 293. http://www.jstor.org/stable/30091976.
  61. Stephen Burge. 2024. 'Angels (malāʾika)', St Andrews Encyclopaedia of Theology. Edited by Brendan N. Wolfe et al. https://www.saet.ac.uk/Islam/Angels Accessed: 21 November 2024 p. 18
  62. Webb, Geoffrey. “Aristotle and the Angels: Convergence of Islam and Christianity.” Studies: An Irish Quarterly Review 79, no. 315 (1990): 293. http://www.jstor.org/stable/30091976.
  63. Lizzini, Olga, "Ibn Sina’s Metaphysics", The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Fall 2021 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.), URL =
  64. Janssens, Jules. "Ibn Sīnā’s Ideas of Ultimate Realities. Neoplatonism and the Qur’ān As Problem-Solving Paradigms in the Avicennian System." Ultimate Reality and Meaning 10.4 (1987): 252-271.
  65. Stephen Burge Angels in Islam: Jalal al-Din al-Suyuti's al-Haba'ik fi akhbar al-mala'ik Routledge 2015 ISBN 978-1-136-50473-0
  66. Erdinç, Z. (2021). The Being and Essence of the Human Soul in al-Taftazanı's Thought. Nazariyat, 7(2).
  67. Stephen Burge. 2024. 'Angels (malāʾika)', St Andrews Encyclopaedia of Theology. Edited by Brendan N. Wolfe et al. https://www.saet.ac.uk/Islam/Angels Accessed: 21 November 2024 p. 18
  68. Erdinç, Z. (2021). The Being and Essence of the Human Soul in al-Taftazanı's Thought. Nazariyat, 7(2).
  69. Tamer, Georges. Islam and Rationality: The Impact of al-Ghazālī. Papers Collected on His 900th Anniversary. Vol. 1. Vol. 94. Brill, 2015. p. 103
  70. Kianifard, Nazanin. "Al-Ghazali’s Compatibility with the Philosophers and the Influence of Sufism." Religious Inquiries 9.17 (2020): 59
  71. Zh. D. Dadebayev, M.T. Kozhakanova, I.K.Azimbayeva Human's Anthropological Appearance in Abai Kunanbayev's Works World Academy of Science, Engineering and TechnologyVol:6 2012-06-23 p. 1065
  72. Seyyed Hossein Nasr An Introduction to Islamic Cosmological Doctrines SUNY Press, 1 January 1993 p. 236
  73. Syrinx von Hees Enzyklopädie als Spiegel des Weltbildes: Qazwīnīs Wunder der Schöpfung: eine Naturkunde des 13. Jahrhunderts Otto Harrassowitz Verlag 2002 page 268
  74. Book: Amira El-Zein . Islam, Arabs, and Intelligent World of the Jinn . 2009 . Syracuse University Press . 34–51 . j.ctt1j5d836 . Wings It is known angels have wings..