| Year | Film | Nominees | |
|---|
1989/90
(35th) |
| The Story of Boys & Girls | Pupi Avati | |
| Dark Illness | Suso Cecchi D'Amico and Tonino Guerra |
| Open Doors | Gianni Amelio, Vincenzo Cerami, and Alessandro Sermoneta |
| Red Wood Pigeon | Nanni Moretti |
| Scugnizzi | Nanni Loy and Elvio Porta |
1990/91
(36th) |
| To Want to Fly | Maurizio Nichetti and Guido Manuli | |
| The Yes Man | Sandro Petraglia, Stefano Rulli and Daniele Luchetti |
| The House of Smiles | Liliane Betti, Marco Ferreri, and Antonino Marino |
| Mediterraneo | Enzo Monteleone |
| The Station | Filippo Ascione, Umberto Marino, and Sergio Rubini |
1991/92
(37th) |
| Damned the Day I Met You | Carlo Verdone and Francesca Marciano | |
| Parenti serpenti | Carmine Amoroso, Suso Cecchi D'Amico, Piero De Bernardi, and Mario Monicelli |
| The Invisible Wall | Sandro Petraglia, Andrea Purgatori, and Stefano Rulli |
| The Stolen Children | Gianni Amelio, Sandro Petraglia, and Stefano Rulli |
1992/93
(38th) |
| The Great Pumpkin | Francesca Archibugi | |
| The Escort | Graziano Diana and Simona Izzo |
| Jonah Who Lived in the Whale | Roberto Faenza and Filippo Ottoni |
1993/94
(39th) |
| For Love, Only for Love | Ugo Chiti and Giovanni Veronesi | |
| Caro diario | Nanni Moretti |
| Let's Not Keep in Touch | Francesca Marciano and Carlo Verdone |
1994/95
(40th) |
| Nemici d'infanzia | Luigi Magni and Carla Vistarini | |
| No Skin | Alessandro D'Alatri |
| Belle al Bar | Alessandro Benvenuti, Ugo Chiti, and Nicola Zavagli |
1995/96
(41st) |
| Celluloide | Furio Scarpelli, Ugo Pirro, and Carlo Lizzani | |
| August Vacation | Francesco Bruni and Paolo Virzì |
| The Star Maker | Fabio Rinaudo and Giuseppe Tornatore |
1996/97
(42nd) |
| Nel profondo paese straniero | Fabio Carpi | |
| The Cyclone | Leonardo Pieraccioni and Giovanni Veronesi |
| The Game Bag | Marco Bechis, Umberto Contarello, Lara Fremder, Gigi Riva, and Maurizio Zaccaro |
| Nirvana | Pino Cacucci, Gloria Corica, and Gabriele Salvatores |
| The Truce | Sandro Petraglia, Francesco Rosi, and Stefano Rulli |
1997/98
(43rd) |
| Life Is Beautiful | Vincenzo Cerami and Roberto Benigni | |
| Notes of Love | Mimmo Calopresti |
| Ovosodo | Paolo Virzì |
1998/99
(44th) |
| Not of this World | Giuseppe Piccioni, Gualtiero Rosella, and Lucia Zei | |
| The Legend of 1900 | Giuseppe Tornatore |
| Marriages | Cristina Comencini | |
| Year | Film | Nominees | |
|---|
1999/00
(45th) |
| Bread and Tulips | Doriana Leondeff and Silvio Soldini | |
| Canone inverso | Simona Izzo and Ricky Tognazzi |
| Olympic Garage | Marco Bechis and Lara Fremder |
2000/01
(46th) |
| One Hundred Steps | Claudio Fava, Monica Capelli, and Marco Tullio Giordana | |
| The Last Kiss | Gabriele Muccino |
| The Son's Room | Linda Ferri, Nanni Moretti, and Heidrun Schleef |
2001/02
(47th) |
| The Profession of Arms | Ermanno Olmi | |
| Burning in the Wind | Doriana Leondeff and Silvio Soldini |
| One Man Up | Paolo Sorrentino |
2002/03
(48th) |
| The Embalmer | Matteo Garrone, Massimo Gaudioso, and Ugo Chiti | |
| Casomai | Alessandro D'Alatri and Anna Pavignano |
| Facing Windows | Gianni Romoli and Ferzan Özpetek |
| It Can't Be All Our Fault | Piero De Bernardi, Pasquale Plastino, Fiamma Satta, and Carlo Verdone |
| My Mother's Smile | Marco Bellocchio |
| Remember Me, My Love | Gabriele Muccino and Heidrun Schleef |
2003/04
(49th) |
| The Best of Youth | Sandro Petraglia and Stefano Rulli | |
| Caterina in the Big City | Francesco Bruni and Paolo Virzì |
| Don't Move | Margaret Mazzantini and Sergio Castellitto |
| Good Morning, Night | Marco Bellocchio |
| What Will Happen to Us | Giovanni Veronesi and Silvio Muccino |
2004/05
(50th) |
| The Consequences of Love | Paolo Sorrentino | |
| After Midnight | Davide Ferrario |
| Cuore Sacro | Gianni Romoli and Ferzan Özpetek |
| The Keys to the House | Gianni Amelio, Sandro Petraglia, and Stefano Rulli |
| Manual of Love | Ugo Chiti and Giovanni Veronesi |
2005/06
(51st) |
| Romanzo criminale | Sandro Petraglia, Stefano Rulli, Giancarlo De Cataldo, and Michele Placido | |
| The Caiman | Nanni Moretti, Francesco Piccolo, and Federica Pontremoli |
| My Best Enemy | Silvio Muccino, Pasquale Plastino, Silvia Ranfagni, and Carlo Verdone |
| Notte prima degli esami | Fausto Brizzi, Massimiliano Bruno, and Marco Martani |
| Our Land | Angelo Pasquini, Carla Cavallucci, and Sergio Rubini |
2006/07
(52nd) |
| My Brother is an Only Child | Daniele Luchetti, Sandro Petraglia, and Stefano Rulli | |
| Along the Ridge | Linda Ferri, Francesco Giammusso, Kim Rossi Stuart, and Federico Starnone |
| Nuovomondo | Emanuele Crialese |
| One Hundred Nails | Ermanno Olmi |
| The Unknown Woman | Giuseppe Tornatore |
2007/08
(53rd) |
| The Girl by the Lake | Sandro Petraglia | |
| Days and Clouds | Doriana Leondeff, Francesco Piccolo, Federica Pontremoli, and Silvio Soldini |
| Quiet Chaos | Nanni Moretti, Laura Paolucci, and Francesco Piccolo |
| The Right Distance | Doriana Leondeff, Carlo Mazzacurati, Marco Pettenello, and Claudio Piersanti |
| The Wind Blows Round | Giorgio Diritti and Fredo Valla |
2008/09
(54th) |
| Gomorrah | Maurizio Braucci, Ugo Chiti, Gianni Di Gregorio, Matteo Garrone, Massimo Gaudioso, and Roberto Saviano | |
| Il Divo | Paolo Sorrentino |
| Many Kisses Later | Fausto Brizzi, Marco Martani, and Massimiliano Bruno |
| We Can Do That | Fabio Bonifacci and Giulio Manfredonia |
| Your Whole Life Ahead of You | Francesco Bruni and Paolo Virzì | |
| Year | Film | Nominees | |
|---|
2009/10
(55th) |
| The First Beautiful Thing | Francesco Bruni, Francesco Piccolo, and Paolo Virzì | |
| Fort Apache Napoli | Jim Carrington, Andrea Purgatori, Marco Risi, and Maurizio Cerino |
| Loose Cannons | Ivan Cotroneo and Ferzan Özpetek |
| The Man Who Will Come | Giorgio Diritti, Giovanni Galavotti, and Tania Pedroni |
| Vincere | Marco Bellocchio and Daniela Ceselli |
2010/11
(56th) |
| Noi credevamo | Mario Martone and Giancarlo De Cataldo | |
| Basilicata Coast to Coast | Rocco Papaleo and Valter Lupo |
| The Immature | |
| La nostra vita | Sandro Petraglia, Stefano Rulli, and Daniele Luchetti |
| A Quiet Life | Filippo Gravino, Guido Iuculano, and Claudio Cupellini |
2011/12
(57th) |
| This Must Be the Place | Paolo Sorrentino and Umberto Contarello | |
| Caesar Must Die | Paolo Taviani, Vittorio Taviani, and Fabio Cavalli |
| Easy! | Francesco Bruni |
| Marco Tullio Giordana, Sandro Petraglia, and Stefano Rulli |
| We Have a Pope | Nanni Moretti, Francesco Piccolo and Federica Ponteremoli |
2012/13
(58th) |
| Long Live Freedom | Roberto Andò and Angelo Pasquini | |
| The Best Offer | Giuseppe Tornatore |
| A Five Star Life | Ivan Cotroneo, Francesca Marciano, and Maria Sole Tognazzi |
| Me and You | Niccolò Ammaniti, Umberto Contarello, Francesca Marciano, and Bernardo Bertolucci |
| Reality | |
2013/14
(59th) |
| Human Capital | Francesco Piccolo, Francesco Bruni, and Paolo Virzì | |
| The Great Beauty | Paolo Sorrentino and Umberto Contarello |
| I Can Quit Whenever I Want | Valerio Attanasio, Andrea Garello, and Sydney Sibilia |
| The Mafia Kills Only in Summer | Michele Astori, Pif, and Marco Martani |
| Miele | Francesca Marciano, Valia Santola, and Valeria Golino |
2014/15
(60th) |
| Black Souls | Francesco Munzi, Fabrizio Ruggirello, and Maurizio Braucci | |
| Hungry Hearts | Saverio Costanzo |
| The Legendary Giulia and Other Miracles | Edoardo Leo and Marco Bonini |
| Leopardi | Mario Martone and Ippolita Di Majo |
| Mia Madre | Nanni Moretti, Francesco Piccolo, and Valia Santella |
2015/16
(61st) |
| Perfect Strangers | Paolo Genovese, Filippo Bologna, Paolo Costella, Paola Mammini, and Rolando Ravello | |
| Don't Be Bad | Claudio Caligari, Francesca Serafini, and Giordano Meacci |
| Tale of Tales | Matteo Garrone, Edoardo Albinati, Ugo Chiti, and Massimo Gaudioso |
| They Call Me Jeeg | Nicola Guaglianone and Menotti |
| Youth | Paolo Sorrentino | |
