American Holocaust: Columbus and the Conquest of the New World explained

American Holocaust: Columbus and the Conquest of the New World is a multidisciplinary book about the Indigenous peoples of the Americas and colonial history written by American scholar and historian David Stannard.

This book generated a significant amount of critical commentary. Stannard responded to some of it in an essay titled "Uniqueness as Denial: The Politics of Genocide Scholarship", published in Is the Holocaust Unique?, edited by Alan S. Rosenbaum.^[1]

Summary

Stannard begins with a description of the cultural and biological diversity in the Americas prior to contact in 1492. The book surveys the history of European colonization in the Americas, for approximately 400 years, from the first Spanish assaults in the Caribbean in the 1490s to the Wounded Knee Massacre in the 1890s--the indigenous inhabitants of North and South America have suffered dispossession, oppression and exploitation. During that time the indigenous population of the Western Hemisphere declined by as many as 100 million people. The author follows the path of colonialism from the Caribbean to Mexico and Central and South America, then North America to Florida, Virginia, and New England, and finally out across the Great Plains and Southwest to California and the North Pacific Coast. Stannard reveals that wherever Europeans or their descendants went, the native people were caught between imported epidemics and colonialism, typically resulting in the annihilation of 95 percent of their populations.

The author explores the history of ancient European and Christian attitudes toward religion, race, and war, he finds the cultural ground well prepared by the end of the Middle Ages for the centuries-long genocide campaign that Europeans and their descendants launched--and in places continue to wage--against indigenous peoples of the Americas.^[2] Stannard suggests that the perpetrators of the American Holocaust drew on the same ideological foundations as did the later architects of the Nazi Holocaust. He writes that the indigenous genocides in the New World were based upon the proposition that American Indians were biologically, racially, and inherently inferior. Thus, the process of “dehumanization” results in sadism and genocide in the personifications of entire peoples (p. 253). It is an ideology of Western supremacy that remains alive today, he adds, and one that in recent years has resulted in American justifications for military interventions overseas.

Stannard concludes that America’s surviving indigenous peoples are still faced with the dilemma going back to 1492. Their choice then was to give up their religion, their lands and culture or suffer further punishment the European colonizers would inflict (p. 258).

Reception

Francis Jennings of Early American Literature ^{[3] [4]} wrote:

Samuel R. Cook of The American Indian Quarterly^[5] wrote:

Wilbur Jacobs in Journal of American Ethnic History^[6] wrote:

Daniel T. Reff from Ohio State University has some praise for the book: "The great strength of this book is the clarification of the many institutional and ideological contingencies that contributed to the American holocaust as well as subsequent genocides".^[7]

See also

• Genocide of indigenous peoples
• Population history of Indigenous peoples of the Americas
• White supremacy
• White nationalism

Further reading

• Bessis, Sophie (2003). Western Supremacy: The Triumph of an Idea? Zed Books. London, UK.
• Stannard, David E. (1992). Genocide in the Americas: Columbus’s Legacy. The Nation, October 19.
• Stannard, David E. (1996). "Uniqueness as Denial: The Politics of Genocide Scholarship", published in Is the Holocaust Unique? edited by Alan S. Rosenbaum. Westview Press. Boulder, Colorado, USA.
• Dunbar-Ortiz, Roxanne (2015). An indigenous peoples' history of the United States. Beacon Press, Boston, USA.
• Lindqvist, Sven (1996). Exterminate all the brutes. New Press, New York, USA.

Notes and References

1. Book: Uniqueness as Denial: The Politics of Genocide Scholarship . Stannard, David E. . 1996 . 245–281 . Westview Press . 0813326419 . English .
2. Cook . Samuel R. . 1995-03-22 . American Holocaust: The Conquest of the New World . The American Indian Quarterly . English . 19 . 2 . 240–242. 10.2307/1185171 . 1185171 .
3. Jennings . Francis . 1994 . Reviews -- American Holocaust: Columbus and the Conquest of the New World by David E. Stannard . Early American Literature . Chapel Hill Press . 29 . 3 . 305–307 . . June 11, 2022.
4. Jennings . Francis . 1994 . Review of American Holocaust: Columbus and the Conquest of the New World . Early American Literature . 29 . 3 . 305–307 . 0012-8163 . 25056991.
5. Cook . Samuel R. . 22 March 1995 . American Holocaust: The Conquest of the New World . The American Indian Quarterly . University of Nebraska Press . 19 . 2 . 240–242 . 10.2307/1185171 . 1185171 . 10 January 2022 . Gale.
6. Jacobs. Wilbur R.. Winter 1996. Reviewed Work: American Holocaust: Columbus and the Conquest of the New World by David E. Stannard. Journal of American Ethnic History. University of Illinois Press. 15. 2. 117–118. 10.2307/1185171. 27502062. 10 June 2022.
7. Reff . Daniel T. . 1994 . Review of American Holocaust: Columbus and the Conquest of the New World . The American Historical Review . 99 . 1 . 189–190 . 10.2307/2166178 . 2166178 . 0002-8762.