New York elected its members November 3–5, 1828.
| District | Incumbent | This race | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Member | Party | First elected | Results | Candidates | |||||
| Silas Wood | Anti-Jacksonian | 1818 | Incumbent lost re-election. New member elected. Jacksonian gain. | nowrap | |||||
| John J. Wood | Jacksonian | 1826 | Incumbent retired. New member elected. Jacksonian hold. | nowrap | |||||
| Churchill C. Cambreleng | Jacksonian | 1821 | Incumbent re-elected. | nowrap rowspan=3 | |||||
| Gulian Verplanck | Jacksonian | 1824 | Incumbent re-elected. | ||||||
| Jeromus Johnson | Jacksonian | 1824 | Incumbent retired. New member elected. Jacksonian hold. | ||||||
| Aaron Ward | Anti-Jacksonian | 1824 | Incumbent retired. New member elected. Anti-Jacksonian hold. | nowrap | |||||
| Thomas J. Oakley | Jacksonian | 1826 | Incumbent resigned May 9, 1828 to become a judge of the superior court of New York City. New member elected. Jacksonian hold. | nowrap | |||||
| John Hallock Jr. | Jacksonian | 1824 | Incumbent retired. New member elected. Jacksonian hold. | nowrap | |||||
| George O. Belden | Jacksonian | 1826 | Incumbent retired. New member elected. Jacksonian hold. | nowrap | |||||
| James Strong | Anti-Jacksonian | 1818 1821 1822 | Incumbent re-elected. | nowrap | |||||
| John D. Dickinson | Anti-Jacksonian | 1818 1822 1826 | Incumbent re-elected. | nowrap | |||||
| Stephen Van Rensselaer | Anti-Jacksonian | 1822 | Incumbent retired. New member elected. Anti-Jacksonian hold. | nowrap | |||||
| Selah R. Hobbie | Jacksonian | 1826 | Incumbent retired. New member elected. Jacksonian hold. | nowrap | |||||
| John I. De Graff | Jacksonian | 1826 | Incumbent retired. New member elected. Jacksonian hold. | nowrap | |||||
| Samuel Chase | Anti-Jacksonian | 1826 | Incumbent retired. New member elected. Jacksonian gain. | nowrap | |||||
| Henry R. Storrs | Anti-Jacksonian | 1816 1821 1822 | Incumbent re-elected. | nowrap | |||||
| Michael Hoffman | Jacksonian | 1824 | Incumbent re-elected. | nowrap | |||||
| Henry Markell | Anti-Jacksonian | 1824 | Incumbent retired. New member elected. Anti-Jacksonian hold. | nowrap | |||||
| John W. Taylor | Anti-Jacksonian | 1812 | Incumbent re-elected. | nowrap | |||||
| Henry C. Martindale | Anti-Jacksonian | 1822 | Incumbent re-elected. | nowrap | |||||
| Richard Keese | Jacksonian | 1826 | Incumbent retired. New member elected. Anti-Jacksonian gain. | nowrap | |||||
| Rudolph Bunner | Jacksonian | 1826 | Incumbent retired. New member elected. Anti-Jacksonian gain. | nowrap rowspan=2 | |||||
| Silas Wright Jr. | Jacksonian | 1826 | Incumbent lost re-election. New member elected. Anti-Jacksonian gain. The losing incumbent later successfully contested the election but Wright never claimed the seat and resigned without serving on March 9, 1830. | ||||||
| John C. Clark | Jacksonian | 1826 | Incumbent retired. New member elected. Jacksonian hold. | nowrap | |||||
| John G. Stower | Jacksonian | 1824 | Incumbent lost re-election. New member elected. Anti-Jacksonian gain. | nowrap | |||||
| Jonas Earll Jr. | Jacksonian | 1826 | Incumbent re-elected. | nowrap | |||||
| Nathaniel Garrow | Jacksonian | 1826 | Incumbent retired. New member elected. Jacksonian hold. | nowrap | |||||
| David Woodcock | Anti-Jacksonian | 1821 1824 1826 | Incumbent lost re-election. New member elected. Jacksonian gain. | nowrap | |||||
| Dudley Marvin | Anti-Jacksonian | 1822 | Incumbent lost re-election. New member elected. Anti-Masonic gain. | nowrap rowspan=2 | |||||
| John Maynard | Anti-Jacksonian | 1826 | Incumbent retired. New member elected. Jacksonian gain. | ||||||
| Daniel D. Barnard | Anti-Jacksonian | 1826 | Incumbent lost re-election. New member elected. Anti-Masonic gain. | nowrap | |||||
| John Magee | Jacksonian | 1826 | Incumbent re-elected. | nowrap | |||||
| Phineas L. Tracy | Anti-Jacksonian | 1827 | Incumbent re-elected to a new party. Anti-Masonic gain. | nowrap | |||||
| Daniel G. Garnsey | Jacksonian | 1824 | Incumbent lost re-election. New member elected. Jacksonian hold. | nowrap | |||||